Biggest changeIncome Tax Expense Absolute Percentage Increase Increase 2023 2022 (Decrease) (Decrease) Provision for income taxes (dollars in millions) $ 3.2 $ 8.9 $ (5.7 ) (64 %) Effective tax rate 51 % 29 % 22 points 19 The increase in the effective tax rate during 2023 as compared to 2022 was primarily due to 1) the impact from the decline in income before taxes to $6.3 million in 2023 from $30.7 million in 2022 and 2) increased non-deductible stock compensation due primarily to the effect from the settlement of share-based awards in 2023.
Biggest changeIncome Tax Expense Absolute Percentage Increase Increase 2024 2023 (Decrease) (Decrease) Provision for income taxes (dollars in millions) $ 8.4 $ 3.2 $ 5.1 159 % Effective tax rate 318 % 51 % 267 points The significant items impacting the effective tax rate during 2024 as compared to 2023 are primarily due to 1) tax expense from the non-deductible goodwill related to the sale of the FeedbackNow product line of $2.5 million, 2) tax expense from the settlement of share-based awards of $1.8 million, 3) foreign withholding taxes of $0.8 million, and 4) state tax expense of $0.6 million related to the write-off of non-realizable state NOL carryforwards due to the dissolution of a domestic subsidiary.
When there is an insufficient history of standalone sales, we use judgment to estimate the standalone selling price, taking into consideration available market conditions, factors used to set list prices, pricing of similar products, and internal pricing objectives. Standalone selling prices are typically analyzed and updated on an annual basis, or as business conditions change.
When there is an insufficient history of standalone sales, we use judgment to estimate the standalone selling price, taking into consideration available market conditions, factors used to set list prices, pricing of similar products, and 15 internal pricing objectives. Standalone selling prices are typically analyzed and updated on an annual basis, or as business conditions change.
We consider all available evidence, both positive and negative, to determine whether, based on the weight of that evidence, a valuation allowance is needed for some portion or 16 all of a net deferred income tax asset. Judgment is required in considering the relative impact of negative and positive evidence.
We consider all available evidence, both positive and negative, to determine whether, based on the weight of that evidence, a valuation allowance is needed for some portion or all of a net deferred income tax asset. Judgment is required in considering the relative impact of negative and positive evidence.
The credit facility permits the Company to increase the revolving credit commitments in an aggregate principal amount up to $50.0 million, subject to approval by the administrative agent and certain customary terms and conditions.
The credit facility 21 permits the Company to increase the revolving credit commitments in an aggregate principal amount up to $50.0 million, subject to approval by the administrative agent and certain customary terms and conditions.
We believe that our current cash balance and cash flows from operations will satisfy working capital, financing activities, and capital expenditure requirements for the next twelve months and to meet our known long-term cash requirements. As of December 31, 2023, we did not have any significant unrecognized tax benefits for uncertain tax positions.
We believe that our current cash balance and cash flows from operations will satisfy working capital, financing activities, and capital expenditure requirements for the next twelve months and to meet our known long-term cash requirements. As of December 31, 2024, we did not have any significant unrecognized tax benefits for uncertain tax positions.
In addition to the contractual cash commitments included above, we have other payables and liabilities that may be legally enforceable but are not considered contractual commitments. See Note 13 – Certain Balance Sheet Accounts in the Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements for more information on our payables and liabilities.
In addition to the contractual cash commitments included above, we have other payables and liabilities that may be legally enforceable but are not considered contractual commitments. See Note 15 – Certain Balance Sheet Accounts in the Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements for more information on our payables and liabilities.
We obtain the 15 standalone selling prices of our products and services based upon an analysis of standalone sales of these products and services.
We obtain the standalone selling prices of our products and services based upon an analysis of standalone sales of these products and services.
We were in full compliance with the covenants as of December 31, 2023 and expect to continue to be in compliance through the next 12 months. Additional future contractual cash obligations extending over the next 12 months and beyond primarily consist of operating lease payments.
We were in full compliance with the covenants as of December 31, 2024 and expect to continue to be in compliance through the next 12 months. Additional future contractual cash obligations extending over the next 12 months and beyond primarily consist of operating lease payments.
During the first quarter of 2023, we recorded an incremental $0.4 million impairment to our California office. We also recorded a $0.6 million charge during the first quarter of 2023 for the write-off of a previously capitalized software project. In the fourth quarter of 2023, we incurred an additional impairment of $0.4 million to our California office.
We also recorded a $0.6 million charge during the first quarter of 2023 for the write-off of a previously capitalized software project. In the fourth quarter of 2023, we recorded an additional impairment of $0.4 million to our California office.
If actual results differ significantly from management’s estimates and projections, there could be a material effect on our financial statements. • Revenue Recognition . We generate revenues from subscriptions to our Research products and services, licensing electronic reprints of our Research, performing consulting projects and advisory services, and hosting events.
If actual results differ significantly from management’s estimates and projections, there could be a material effect on our financial statements. • Revenue Recognition . We generate revenues from subscriptions to our Research products and services, subscriptions to, and individual licenses of, electronic reprints of our Research, performing consulting projects and advisory services, and hosting events.
Results of Operations for the years ended December 31, 2023 and 2022 The following table sets forth our Consolidated Statements of Operations as a percentage of total revenues for the years noted.
Results of Operations for the years ended December 31, 2024 and 2023 The following table sets forth our Consolidated Statements of Operations as a percentage of total revenues for the years noted.
In arriving at these judgments, the weight given to the potential effect of negative and positive evidence is commensurate with the extent to which it can be objectively verified. As of December 31, 2023 and 2022, we maintained a valuation allowance of $1.1 million and $1.0 million, respectively, primarily relating to foreign net operating loss carryforwards from an acquisition.
In arriving at these judgments, the weight given to the potential effect of negative and positive evidence is commensurate with the extent to which it can be objectively verified. As of December 31, 2024 and 2023, we maintained a valuation allowance of $1.1 million, primarily relating to foreign net operating loss carryforwards from an acquisition.
Any resulting impairment loss could have a material adverse impact on our results of operations. Intangible assets with finite lives as of December 31, 2023 consist of acquired customer relationships, acquired technology, and acquired trademarks and were valued according to the future cash flows they were estimated to produce or the estimated costs to replace the assets.
Any resulting impairment loss could have a material adverse impact on our results of operations. Intangible assets with finite lives as of December 31, 2024 consist of acquired customer relationships, acquired technology, and acquired trademarks and were valued using the future cash flows they were estimated to produce or the estimated costs to replace the assets.
Item 7. Management’s Discussion and Analysis of Financial Condition and Results of Operations Overview We derive revenues from subscriptions to our Research products and services, licensing electronic “reprints” of our Research, performing consulting projects and advisory services, and hosting events.
Item 7. Management’s Discussion and Analysis of Financial Condition and Results of Operations Overview We derive revenues from subscriptions to our Research products and services, subscriptions to, and individual licenses of, electronic “reprints” of our Research, performing consulting projects and advisory services, and hosting events.
We lease office space under non-cancelable operating lease agreements (refer to Note 5 – Leases in the Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements for additional information). The remaining duration of non-cancelable office space leases ranges from less than 1 year to 8 years.
We lease office space under non-cancelable operating lease agreements (refer to Note 6 – Leases in the Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements for additional information). The remaining duration of non-cancelable office space leases ranges from less than 1 year to 7 years.
Segment expenses include the direct expenses of each segment organization and exclude selling and marketing expenses, general and administrative expenses, stock-based compensation expense, depreciation expense, adjustments to incentive bonus compensation from target amounts, amortization of intangible assets, restructuring and integration costs, interest and other income (expense), and gains on investments.
Segment expenses include the direct expenses of each segment organization and exclude selling and marketing expenses, general and administrative expenses, stock-based compensation expense, depreciation expense, adjustments to incentive bonus compensation from target amounts, amortization of intangible assets, restructuring costs, loss from sale of divested operation, interest expense, other income, and gains on investments.
As of December 31, 2023, our remaining stock repurchase authorization was approximately $70.9 million. The Company has a credit facility that provides up to $150.0 million of revolving credit commitments. Amount outstanding under the credit facility was $35.0 million at December 31, 2023 and the facility expires in December of 2026.
As of December 31, 2024, our remaining stock repurchase authorization was approximately $80.0 million. The Company has a credit facility that provides up to $150.0 million of revolving credit commitments. The amount outstanding under the credit facility was $35.0 million at December 31, 2024 and the facility expires in December of 2026.
The decrease in our retention rates and number of clients from the prior year period is primarily attributable to 1) macroeconomic conditions affecting our client base including a) funding and budget pressure on our smaller technology clients and the technology industry in general, and b) the uncertain economic conditions caused by inflation, increased interest rates, geopolitical turbulence, and the threat of recession during 2023, and 2) the ongoing transition of our client base to our Forrester Decisions product platform that was launched in August 2021.
The decrease in the number of clients from the prior year period is primarily attributable to 1) macroeconomic conditions affecting our client base including a) funding and budget pressure on our smaller technology clients and the technology industry in general, and b) the uncertain economic conditions during the past year caused by inflation, high interest rates, and geopolitical turbulence, and 2) the transition of our client base to our Forrester Decisions product platform that was launched in August 2021.
As of December 31, 2023, we had $281.9 million of goodwill and intangible assets with finite lives recorded in our Consolidated Balance Sheets. When acquiring a business, as of the acquisition date, we determine the estimated fair values of the assets acquired and liabilities assumed, which may include a significant amount of intangible assets and goodwill.
As of December 31, 2024, we had $255.4 million of goodwill and intangible assets with finite lives recorded in our Consolidated Balance Sheets. When acquiring a business, as of the acquisition date, we determine the estimated fair values of the assets acquired and liabilities assumed, which may include a significant amount of intangible assets and goodwill.
Although write-offs of customer receivables have not been significant during the last three years ($0.7 million, $0.7 million, and $0.3 million during 2023, 2022, and 2021, respectively), if our customers' financial condition were to deteriorate unexpectedly, we could experience a significant increase in our expense.
Although write-offs of customer receivables have not been significant during the last three years ($0.7 million each year during 2024, 2023, and 2022), if our customers' financial condition were to deteriorate unexpectedly, we could experience a significant increase in our expense.
Research revenues decreased 6% during 2023 compared to 2022 primarily due to the decrease in CV for the year, as discussed above. From a product perspective, the decrease in revenues was primarily due to a decline in revenue from our reprint product and our other smaller and discontinued products.
Research revenues decreased 5% during 2024 compared to 2023 primarily due to the decrease in CV, as discussed above. From a product perspective, the decrease in revenues was primarily due to a decline in revenue from our reprint product and our other smaller and discontinued products.
Research segment costs include the cost of the organizations responsible for developing and delivering these products in addition to the cost of the product management organization that is responsible for product pricing and packaging and the launch of new products. The Consulting segment includes the revenues and the related costs of our project consulting organization.
Research segment costs include the cost of the organizations responsible for developing and delivering these products in addition to the cost of the product management organization that is responsible for product pricing and packaging and the launch of new products.
Wallet retention is calculated on a percentage basis by dividing the annualized contract value of our current clients, who were also clients a year ago, by the total annualized contract value from a year ago. 14 • Clients — is calculated at the enterprise level as all clients that have an active CV contract.
Wallet retention is calculated on a percentage basis by dividing the annualized contract value of our current clients, who were also clients a year ago, by the total annualized contract value from a year ago. • Clients — is calculated at the enterprise level as all clients that have an active CV contract. 14 Client retention and wallet retention are not necessarily indicative of the rate of future retention of our revenue base.
Years Ended December 31, 2023 2022 Revenues: Research revenues 69.6 % 65.9 % Consulting revenues 24.6 28.4 Events revenues 5.8 5.7 Total revenues 100.0 100.0 Operating expenses: Cost of services and fulfillment 42.5 41.6 Selling and marketing 34.8 33.8 General and administrative 14.2 12.6 Depreciation 1.8 1.7 Amortization of intangible assets 2.5 2.5 Restructuring costs 2.8 1.7 Income from operations 1.4 6.1 Interest expense (0.6 ) (0.5 ) Other income, net 0.5 — Gains on investments, net — 0.1 Income before income taxes 1.3 5.7 Income tax expense 0.7 1.6 Net income 0.6 % 4.1 % 2023 compared to 2022 Revenues Absolute Percentage Increase Increase 2023 2022 (Decrease) (Decrease) (dollars in millions) Total revenues $ 480.8 $ 537.8 $ (57.0 ) (11 %) Research revenues $ 334.4 $ 354.5 $ (20.1 ) (6 %) Consulting revenues $ 118.2 $ 152.6 $ (34.4 ) (23 %) Events revenues $ 28.2 $ 30.7 $ (2.6 ) (8 %) Revenues attributable to customers outside of the U.S. $ 107.3 $ 111.7 $ (4.4 ) (4 %) Percentage of revenue attributable to customers outside of the U.S. 22 % 21 % 1 point Research revenues are recognized as revenue primarily on a ratable basis over the term of the contracts, which are generally 12 or 24-month periods.
Years Ended December 31, 2024 2023 Revenues: Research revenues 73.2 % 69.6 % Consulting revenues 22.5 24.6 Events revenues 4.3 5.8 Total revenues 100.0 100.0 Operating expenses: Cost of services and fulfillment 42.2 42.5 Selling and marketing 36.9 34.8 General and administrative 13.6 14.2 Depreciation 1.8 1.8 Amortization of intangible assets 2.2 2.5 Restructuring costs 2.7 2.8 Loss from sale of divested operation 0.4 — Income from operations 0.2 1.4 Interest expense (0.7 ) (0.6 ) Other income, net 0.9 0.5 Gains on investments, net 0.2 — Income before income taxes 0.6 1.3 Income tax expense 1.9 0.7 Net income (loss) (1.3 %) 0.6 % 2024 compared to 2023 Revenues Absolute Percentage Increase Increase 2024 2023 (Decrease) (Decrease) (dollars in millions) Total revenues $ 432.5 $ 480.8 $ (48.3 ) (10 %) Research revenues $ 316.7 $ 334.4 $ (17.7 ) (5 %) Consulting revenues $ 97.3 $ 118.2 $ (21.0 ) (18 %) Events revenues $ 18.5 $ 28.2 $ (9.7 ) (34 %) Revenues attributable to customers outside of the U.S. $ 98.4 $ 107.3 $ (8.9 ) (8 %) Percentage of revenue attributable to customers outside of the U.S. 23 % 22 % 1 point Research revenues are recognized as revenue primarily on a ratable basis over the term of the contracts, which are generally 12 or 24-month periods.
During 2022, we recorded $3.7 million of right-of-use asset impairments and $1.3 million of leasehold improvement impairments related to closing one floor of our offices located at 150 Spear Street, San Francisco, California. • Income Taxes .
During 2022, we recorded $3.7 million of right-of-use asset impairments and $1.3 million of leasehold improvement impairments related to closing the 10th floor of our offices located in San Francisco, California. 16 • Income Taxes .
Reprints include an obligation to deliver a customer-selected research document and certain usage data provided through an on-line platform, which represents two performance obligations. We recognize revenue for the performance obligation for the data portion of the reprint ratably over the license term.
Subscription products are recognized as revenue over the term of the contract. Individual reprint licenses include an obligation to deliver a customer-selected research document and certain usage data provided through our platform, which represents two performance obligations. We recognize revenue for the performance obligation for the data portion of the reprint ratably over the license term.
The ongoing macroeconomic conditions and product transition are anticipated to pressure our key metrics through 2024. Critical Accounting Estimates Management’s discussion and analysis of financial condition and results of operations are based upon our consolidated financial statements, which have been prepared in accordance with generally accepted accounting principles in the United States of America (“GAAP”).
Critical Accounting Estimates Management’s discussion and analysis of financial condition and results of operations are based upon our consolidated financial statements, which have been prepared in accordance with generally accepted accounting principles in the United States of America (“GAAP”).
During 2022, we used cash in investing activities of $6.8 million, which consisted of $5.7 million of purchases of property and equipment, primarily consisting of computer software and equipment, and $1.4 million in net purchases of marketable investments.
During 2023, we used cash in investing activities of $36.8 million, which consisted of $31.3 million in net purchases of marketable investments and $5.5 million of purchases of property and equipment, primarily consisting of computer software.
General and Administrative Absolute Percentage Increase Increase 2023 2022 (Decrease) (Decrease) General and administrative expenses (dollars in millions) $ 68.5 $ 67.7 $ 0.8 1 % General and administrative expenses as a percentage of total revenues 14 % 13 % 1 point General and administrative employees (at end of period) 281 309 (28 ) (9 %) General and administrative expenses increased 1% in 2023 compared to 2022.
General and Administrative Absolute Percentage Increase Increase 2024 2023 (Decrease) (Decrease) General and administrative expenses (dollars in millions) $ 58.8 $ 68.5 $ (9.7 ) (14 %) General and administrative expenses as a percentage of total revenues 14 % 14 % — General and administrative employees (at end of period) 253 281 (28 ) (10 %) General and administrative expenses decreased 14% in 2024 compared to 2023.
Contract value is calculated as the annualized value of all contracts in effect at a specific point in time, without regard to how much revenue has already been recognized.
We define these metrics as follows: • Contract value (CV) — is defined as the value attributable to all of our recurring research-related contracts. Contract value is calculated as the annualized value of all contracts in effect at a specific point in time, without regard to how much revenue has already been recognized.
Consulting segment expenses decreased 21% during 2023 compared to 2022. The decrease in expenses was primarily due to (1) a $8.4 million decrease in professional services primarily due to a decrease in contractor costs, outsourced expenses, and consulting fees and (2) a $3.3 million decrease in compensation and benefit costs primarily due to a decrease in headcount and benefit costs.
The decrease in expenses was primarily due to (1) an $8.4 million decrease in compensation and benefit costs primarily due to a decrease in headcount and (2) a $1.0 million decrease in professional services primarily due to a decrease in survey costs. Consulting segment revenues decreased 15% during 2024 compared to 2023.
If the cash outside of the U.S. is needed for operations in the U.S., we would be required to accrue and pay U.S. state taxes and may be required to pay withholding taxes to foreign jurisdictions to repatriate these funds. 21 However, our intent is to permanently reinvest these funds outside of the U.S. and our current plans do not demonstrate a need to repatriate these funds for our U.S. operations.
If the cash outside of the U.S. is needed for operations in the U.S., we would be required to accrue and pay U.S. state taxes and may be required to pay withholding taxes to foreign jurisdictions to repatriate these funds.
As of December 31, 2023, we had cash, cash equivalents, and marketable investments of $124.5 million. This balance includes $75.8 million held outside of the U.S.
As of December 31, 2024, we had cash, cash equivalents, and marketable investments of $104.7 million. This balance includes $70.7 million held outside of the U.S.
Events revenues consist of ticket and sponsorship sales for a Forrester-hosted event. Billings for events are also initially recorded as deferred revenue and are recognized as revenue upon completion of each event. Our primary operating expenses consist of cost of services and fulfillment, selling and marketing expenses, and general and administrative expenses.
Advisory service revenues, such as speeches and advisory days, are recognized when the service is complete. Events revenues consist of ticket and sponsorship sales for a Forrester-hosted event, and revenue is recognized upon completion of each event. Our primary operating expenses consist of cost of services and fulfillment, selling and marketing expenses, and general and administrative expenses.
We recognize revenue for the performance obligation for the research document at the time of providing access to the document. Billings for licensing of reprints are initially recorded as deferred revenue. Clients purchase consulting projects and advisory services independently and/or to supplement their access to our subscription-based products.
We recognize revenue for the performance obligation for the research document at the time of providing access to the document. Clients purchase consulting projects and advisory services independently and/or to supplement their access to our subscription-based products. Consulting project revenues, which are based upon fixed-fee agreements, are recognized as the services are provided.
Other income (expense), net increased by $2.1 million in 2023 compared to 2022 primarily due to an increase in interest income due to higher interest rates in 2023. Gains on Investments, Net Gains on investments, net primarily represents our share of equity method investment gains and losses from our technology-related investment funds.
Other income, net increased by $1.7 million in 2024 compared to 2023 primarily due to a $2.1 million increase in interest income, partially offset by a $0.5 million increase in foreign currency exchange losses. 19 Gains on Investments, Net Gains on investments, net primarily represents our share of equity method investment gains and losses from our technology-related investment funds.
Event segment revenues decreased 8% during 2023 compared to 2022. The decrease in revenues was primarily due to a decrease in sponsorship revenues. Event segment expenses decreased 6% during 2023 compared to 2022. The decrease in expenses was primarily due to a $1.1 million decrease in compensation and benefits costs primarily due to a decrease in headcount and benefit costs.
The decrease in expenses was primarily due to (1) a $6.5 million decrease in compensation and benefit costs primarily due to a decrease in headcount and (2) a $0.5 million decrease in professional services primarily due to a decrease in contractor costs. Event segment revenues decreased 34% during 2024 compared to 2023.
Cost of Services and Fulfillment Absolute Percentage Increase Increase 2023 2022 (Decrease) (Decrease) Cost of services and fulfillment (dollars in millions) $ 204.5 $ 223.8 $ (19.3 ) (9 %) Cost of services and fulfillment as a percentage of total revenues 43 % 42 % 1 point Service and fulfillment employees (at end of period) 781 920 (139 ) (15 %) Cost of services and fulfillment expenses decreased 9% in 2023 compared to 2022.
Cost of Services and Fulfillment Absolute Percentage Increase Increase 2024 2023 (Decrease) (Decrease) Cost of services and fulfillment (dollars in millions) $ 182.5 $ 204.5 $ (22.0 ) (11 %) Cost of services and fulfillment as a percentage of total revenues 42 % 43 % (1) point Service and fulfillment employees (at end of period) 680 781 (101 ) (13 %) Cost of services and fulfillment expenses decreased 11% in 2024 compared to 2023.
We have included the recast CV and Wallet Retention metrics below for the period ended December 31, 2022, and we have also provided recast CV and Wallet Retention amounts dating back to the fourth quarter of 2021, on the investor relations section of our website.
We have included the recast metrics below for the period ended December 31, 2023, and we have also provided recast metrics dating back to the fourth quarter of 2022, on the investor relations section of our website. Contract value, client retention, wallet retention, and number of clients are metrics that we believe are important to understanding our research business.
Remaining lease payments within one year, within two to three years, within four to five years, and after five years from December 31, 2023 are $16.0 million, $26.2 million, $8.6 million, and $6.0 million, respectively.
Remaining lease payments within one year, within two to three years, within four to five years, and after five years from December 31, 2024 are $13.9 million, $18.0 million, $5.7 million, and $3.2 million, respectively.
The remaining $1.3 million of the severance and related costs for this plan will be paid during 2024. In February 2024, we implemented a reduction in force of approximately 3% of our workforce across various geographies and functions to better align our cost structure with our revenue outlook for 2024.
In January 2025, we implemented a reduction in force of approximately 6% of our workforce across various geographies and functions to better align our cost structure with our revenue outlook for 2025. Approximately $4.2 million of severance and related costs for this action were recorded during the fourth quarter of 2024.
In addition, revenue from our subscription research products was essentially consistent as revenue growth from the Forrester Decisions product was offset by declines in our legacy research products. Consulting revenues decreased 23% during 2023 compared to 2022.
In addition, revenue from our subscription research products declined 1% 17 during 2024 compared to 2023, as revenue growth from our Forrester Decisions products was offset by revenue declines from our heritage research products. Consulting revenues decreased 18% during 2024 compared to 2023.
The project consulting organization delivers a majority of our project consulting revenue and certain advisory services. The Events segment includes the revenues and the costs of the organization responsible for developing and hosting in-person and virtual events. We evaluate reportable segment performance and allocate resources based on segment revenues and expenses.
The Consulting segment includes the revenues and the related costs of our project consulting organization. The project consulting organization delivers a majority of our project consulting revenue. The Events segment includes the revenues and the costs of the organization responsible for developing and hosting in-person and virtual events.
During 2023, we recorded $1.9 million of right-of-use asset impairments and accelerated amortization and $0.7 million of leasehold improvement impairments related to closing various offices.
During 2024, we recorded $3.6 million of right-of-use asset impairments and $1.0 million of leasehold improvement impairments related to the closure of the 10th and 11th floors of our offices located in San Francisco, California. During 2023, we recorded $1.9 million of right-of-use asset impairments and accelerated amortization and $0.7 million of leasehold improvement impairments related to closing various offices.
We offer contracts for our Research products as either multi-year contracts or annual contracts, which are typically payable in advance on an annual basis. Subscription products are recognized as revenue over the term of the contract. Accordingly, a substantial portion of our billings are initially recorded as deferred revenue.
We offer contracts for our products as either multi-year contracts or annual contracts, which are typically payable in advance on an annual basis. For certain contracts, we offer to invoice the contract price in multiple invoices throughout the year. Billings in excess of revenue recognized are recorded as deferred revenue.
Events revenues decreased 8% during 2023 compared to 2022. The decrease in revenues was primarily due to a decrease in sponsorship revenues. 17 Refer to the “Segment Results” section below for a discussion of revenue and expenses by segment.
The decrease in revenues was due to a decrease in delivery of consulting services due to lower client bookings. Events revenues decreased 34% during 2024 compared to 2023. The decrease in revenues was due to decreases in both sponsorship revenues and event ticket revenues. Refer to the “Segment Results” section below for a discussion of revenue and expenses by segment.
We recorded a restructuring charge of $5.0 million during the fourth quarter of 2022 related to closing one floor of our offices in California, of which $3.7 million related to an impairment of a right-of-use asset and $1.3 million related to an impairment of leasehold improvements.
We recorded a restructuring charge of $5.0 million during the fourth quarter of 2022 related to closing one floor of our offices in California. During the first quarter of 2023, we recorded an incremental $0.4 million impairment to our California office.
During 2022, we used $38.9 million of cash from financing activities primarily due to $25.0 million of discretionary repayments of our revolving credit facility and $15.1 million for purchases of our common stock, partially offset by $1.2 million of net proceeds from the issuance of common stock under our stock-based incentive plans.
During 2024, we used $16.1 million of cash from financing activities primarily due $15.9 million for purchases of our common stock and $2.6 million in taxes paid related to net share settlements of restricted stock units, partially offset by $2.4 million of net proceeds from the issuance of common stock under our stock-based incentive plans.
The decrease was primarily due to (1) a $10.2 million decrease in professional services costs primarily due to a decrease in contractor costs, outsourced expenses, and consulting fees, (2) a $7.7 million decrease in compensation and benefit costs due to a decrease in headcount, incentive bonus costs, and benefit costs (due to the introduction of the flexible vacation and personal paid time off policy in the United States), (3) a $1.0 million decrease in facilities costs due to a decrease in the number of facilities being leased, and (4) a $0.7 million decrease in software costs.
The decrease was primarily due to (1) a $18.1 million decrease in compensation and benefit costs due to a decrease in headcount and incentive bonus costs, partially offset by an increase in benefit costs (mainly due to a benefit during 2023 resulting from the introduction of the flexible vacation and personal paid time off policy in the United States), (2) a $1.6 million decrease in professional services costs primarily due to a decrease in survey costs and contractor costs, (3) a $1.0 million decrease in facilities costs, and (4) a $0.8 million decrease in event expenses.
Selling and Marketing Absolute Percentage Increase Increase 2023 2022 (Decrease) (Decrease) Selling and marketing expenses (dollars in millions) $ 167.4 $ 181.9 $ (14.6 ) (8 %) Selling and marketing expenses as a percentage of total revenues 35 % 34 % 1 point Selling and marketing employees (at end of period) 682 804 (122 ) (15 %) Selling and marketing expenses decreased 8% in 2023 compared to 2022.
Selling and Marketing Absolute Percentage Increase Increase 2024 2023 (Decrease) (Decrease) Selling and marketing expenses (dollars in millions) $ 159.6 $ 167.4 $ (7.7 ) (5 %) Selling and marketing expenses as a percentage of total revenues 37 % 35 % 2 points Selling and marketing employees (at end of period) 638 682 (44 ) (6 %) Selling and marketing expenses decreased 5% in 2024 compared to 2023.
The decrease was primarily due to (1) an $11.9 million decrease in compensation and benefit costs due to a decrease in commissions expense, headcount, incentive bonus costs, and benefit costs (due to the introduction of the flexible vacation and personal paid time off policy in the United States), (2) a $1.1 million decrease in professional services costs primarily due to a decrease in consulting fees and advertising costs, and (3) a $0.9 million decrease in facilities costs due to a decrease in the number of facilities being leased.
The decrease was primarily due to (1) a $8.1 million decrease in compensation and benefit costs due to a decrease in headcount, commissions expense, and incentive bonus costs, partially offset by an increase in benefit costs (mainly due to a benefit during 2023 resulting from the introduction of the flexible vacation and personal paid time off policy in the United States) and (2) a $0.8 million decrease in stock compensation expense.
We recorded $4.3 million of severance and related costs for this action during the fourth quarter of 2022, and $0.6 million during the first quarter of 2023.
Restructuring In January 2023, we implemented a reduction in our workforce of approximately 4% across various geographies and functions to streamline operations. We recorded $4.3 million of severance and related costs for this action during the fourth quarter of 2022, and $0.6 million during the first quarter of 2023.
A detailed description and analysis of the fiscal year 2021 year-over-year changes can be found in Item 7. Management’s Discussion and Analysis of Financial Condition and Results of Operations in our Annual Report on Form 10-K for the year ended December 31, 2022. Liquidity and Capital Resources We have historically financed our operations primarily through funds generated from operations.
Management’s Discussion and Analysis of Financial Condition and Results of Operations in our Annual Report on Form 10-K for the year ended December 31, 2023. Liquidity and Capital Resources We have historically financed our operations primarily through funds generated from operations. Research revenues, which constituted 73% of our revenues during 2024, are generally renewable and are typically payable in advance.
Our CV products make up essentially all of our research revenues, and research revenues as a percentage of total revenues increased from approximately 66% in 2022 to approximately 70% in 2023.
Our CV products make up essentially all of our research revenues, and research revenues as a percentage of total revenues increased from approximately 70% in 2023 to approximately 73% in 2024. We calculate CV at the foreign currency rates used for internal planning purposes each year.
Interest expense increased by $0.6 million in 2023 compared to 2022 due to an increase in the annualized interest rate on our borrowings, which was partially offset by lower average outstanding borrowings. Other Income (Expense), Net Other income (expense), net primarily consists of interest income, gains and losses on foreign currency, and gains and losses on foreign currency forward contracts.
Interest Expense Interest expense consists of interest on our borrowings. The fluctuation for interest expense was immaterial in 2024 compared to 2023. Other Income, Net Other income, net primarily consists of interest income, gains and losses on foreign currency, and gains and losses on foreign currency forward contracts.
As of December 31, 2023 and January 1, 2024, approximately 62% and 66%, respectively, of our overall CV was in our Forrester Decisions product platform. In the longer term, we anticipate that approximately 80% of our CV will be in our Forrester Decisions product platform. The remaining approximate 20% of CV represents non-Forrester Decisions CV products, primarily reprints.
As of December 31, 2024, approximately 80% of our overall CV was in our Forrester Decisions product platform compared to 62% at December 31, 2023. The remaining CV at December 31, 2024 represents our reprints products at approximately 12% of CV, and our heritage research products at approximately 8% of CV.
Absent an event that indicates a specific impairment may exist, we have selected November 30th as the date to perform the annual goodwill impairment test.
Absent an event that indicates a specific impairment may exist, we have selected November 30th as the date to perform the annual goodwill impairment test. We completed the annual goodwill impairment testing as of November 30, 2024 utilizing a qualitative assessment to determine if the fair values of each of our reporting units was less than their respective carrying values.
In addition, revenue from our subscription research products was essentially consistent as revenue growth from the Forrester Decisions product was offset by declines in our legacy research products. Consulting product revenues within this segment decreased 31% primarily due to decreased delivery of consulting and advisory services by our research analysts due primarily to lower client bookings for these services.
Research product revenues within this segment decreased 5% primarily due to the decrease in CV, as discussed above. Consulting product revenues within this segment decreased 27% primarily due to decreased delivery of consulting and advisory services by our research analysts due primarily to lower client bookings for these services. Research segment expenses decreased 8% during 2024 compared to 2023.
Client retention decreased by 1 percentage point and wallet retention decreased by 7 percentage points during 2023 compared to 2022. However, client retention was consistent compared to the prior quarter and wallet retention decreased by 2 percentage points to the prior quarter.
Client retention was flat compared to the prior year period, however wallet retention improved by 2 percentage points.
We expect amortization expense related to our intangible assets to be approximately $10.0 million for the year ending December 31, 2024. Restructuring In January 2023, we implemented a reduction in our workforce of approximately 4% across various geographies and functions to streamline operations.
Amortization of Intangible Assets Amortization expense decreased by $2.3 million in 2024 compared to 2023 primarily due to a decrease in the amortization of trademark and technology intangible assets. We expect amortization expense related to our intangible assets to be approximately $8.7 million for the year ending December 31, 2025.
A summary of our key metrics is as follows (dollars in millions): As of Absolute Percentage December 31, Increase Increase 2023 2022 (Decrease) (Decrease) Contract value $ 332.1 $ 345.4 $ (13.3 ) (4 %) Client retention 73 % 74 % (1) point Wallet retention 87 % 94 % (7) points Number of clients 2,449 2,778 (329 ) (12 %) Contract value during 2023 decreased by 4% compared to 2022 due to lower enrichment of retained customers and a decrease in client count.
A summary of our key metrics is as follows (dollars in millions): As of Absolute Percentage December 31, Increase Increase 2024 2023 (Decrease) (Decrease) Contract value $ 307.6 $ 323.6 $ (16.0 ) (5 %) Client retention 73 % 73 % — Wallet retention 89 % 87 % 2 points Number of clients 1,942 2,257 (315 ) (14 %) Contract value during 2024 decreased by 5% compared to 2023 due to wallet retention being at 89% for the period (representing retention and enrichment of the prior year CV base) and new client acquisition not fully offsetting the net retention loss.
Research revenues, which constituted 70% of our revenues during 2023, are generally renewable and are typically payable in advance. We generated cash from operating activities of $21.7 million and $39.4 million during the years ended December 31, 2023 and 2022, respectively.
We used $3.9 million of cash in operating activities during the year ended December 31, 2024 and generated $21.7 million of cash from operating activities during the year ended December 31, 2023.
Notification to affected persons commenced in December 2023 and was completed by the end of February 2024. Approximately $0.7 million of severance and related costs for this action were recorded during the fourth quarter of 2023. We expect a majority of the severance and related costs for this plan to be paid during 2024.
We recorded $0.7 million of severance and related costs for this action during the fourth quarter of 2023, and $2.8 million during the first quarter of 2024. We recorded a restructuring charge of $3.8 million during the first quarter of 2024 related to closing one floor of our offices in California.
These increases were partially offset by a $1.4 million decrease in compensation and benefit costs due to a decrease in incentive bonus costs, benefit costs (due to the introduction of the flexible vacation and personal paid time off policy in the United States), and capitalized salaries for internal-use software projects.
The decrease was primarily due to (1) a $5.6 million decrease in legal costs, due primarily to a $4.8 million provision for a legal settlement recorded in 2023 for a wage-related matter and (2) a $3.8 million decrease in compensation and benefit costs due to a decrease in headcount and incentive bonus costs, partially offset by an increase in benefit costs (mainly due to a benefit during 2023 resulting from the introduction of the flexible vacation and personal paid time off policy in the United States). 18 Depreciation Depreciation expense decreased by $0.9 million in 2024 compared to 2023 primarily due to certain software assets becoming fully depreciated.
As a result of closing the offices, we recorded restructuring costs of $2.3 million, which included $1.3 million related to right-of-use asset impairments and accelerated amortization and $0.6 million related to impairments of leasehold improvements. We also incurred $0.7 million in contract termination costs.
As a result of closing the offices, we recorded restructuring costs of $2.3 million. We also incurred $0.7 million in contract termination costs. In February 2024, we implemented a reduction in our workforce of approximately 3% across various geographies and functions to better align our cost structure with the revenue outlook for the year.
The $17.8 million decrease in cash provided from operations during 2023 was primarily due to an $18.8 million decrease in net income. During 2023, we used cash in investing activities of $36.8 million, which consisted of $31.3 million in net purchases of marketable investments and $5.5 million of purchases of property and equipment, primarily consisting of computer software.
During 2024, we generated cash from investing activities of $5.0 million primarily from $6.0 million in proceeds from the sale of the FeedbackNow product line and $2.5 million in net maturities and sales of marketable investments, partially offset by $3.4 million of purchases of property and equipment, primarily consisting of computer software.
Research Segment Consulting Segment Events Segment Consolidated Year Ended December 31, 2023 (In thousands, except percentages) Research revenues $ 334,396 $ — $ — $ 334,396 Consulting revenues 28,826 89,402 — 118,228 Events revenues — — 28,155 28,155 Total segment revenues 363,222 89,402 28,155 480,779 Segment expenses (132,444 ) (45,028 ) (20,557 ) (198,029 ) Year over year revenue change (8 %) (19 %) (8 %) (11 %) Year over year expense change (1 %) (21 %) (6 %) (7 %) Research Segment Consulting Segment Events Segment Consolidated Year Ended December 31, 2022 (In thousands) Research revenues $ 354,453 $ — $ — $ 354,453 Consulting revenues 41,559 111,028 — 152,587 Events revenues — — 30,747 30,747 Total segment revenues 396,012 111,028 30,747 537,787 Segment expenses (133,566 ) (56,889 ) (21,801 ) (212,256 ) Research segment revenues decreased 8% during 2023 compared to 2022.
Research Segment Consulting Segment Events Segment Consolidated Year Ended December 31, 2024 (In thousands, except percentages) Research revenues $ 316,739 $ — $ — $ 316,739 Consulting revenues 21,095 76,159 — 97,254 Events revenues — — 18,477 18,477 Total segment revenues 337,834 76,159 18,477 432,470 Segment expenses (115,651 ) (37,828 ) (19,250 ) (172,729 ) Segment operating income (loss) 222,183 38,331 (773 ) 259,741 Year over year revenue change (7 %) (15 %) (34 %) (10 %) Year over year expense change (8 %) (16 %) (6 %) (10 %) 20 Research Segment Consulting Segment Events Segment Consolidated Year Ended December 31, 2023 (In thousands) Research revenues $ 334,396 $ — $ — $ 334,396 Consulting revenues 28,826 89,402 — 118,228 Events revenues — — 28,155 28,155 Total segment revenues 363,222 89,402 28,155 480,779 Segment expenses (125,392 ) (45,028 ) (20,557 ) (190,977 ) Segment operating income 237,830 44,374 7,598 289,802 Research segment revenues decreased 7% during 2024 compared to 2023.
The decrease in expenses was primarily due to a $2.0 million decrease in professional services primarily due to a decrease in contractor costs and consulting fees, partially offset by a $0.6 million increase in compensation and benefit costs primarily due to merit increases. 20 Consulting segment revenues decreased 19% during 2023 compared to 2022.
The decrease in revenues was due to a decrease in both sponsorship revenues and event ticket revenues. Event segment expenses decreased 6% during 2024 compared to 2023.
These decreases were partially offset by a $0.6 million increase in stock compensation expense.
These decreases were partially offset by a $1.4 million increase in professional services costs primarily due to an increase in consulting fees, partially offset by a decrease in advertising costs.