Biggest changeIn these tables, adjustments are made to the yields on tax-exempt assets in order to present tax-exempt income and fully taxable income on a comparable basis. Year ended December 31, 2022 2021 2020 Interest Average Interest Average Interest Average Average Income/ Yield/ Average Income/ Yield/ Average Income/ Yield/ (dollars in thousands) Balance Expense Rate Balance Expense Rate Balance Expense Rate Interest Earning Assets Interest-bearing deposits with banks $ 58,149 $ 586 1.01 % $ 222,916 $ 322 0.14 % 162,616 $ 664 0.41 % Investment securities (1) 1,135,426 24,333 2.14 % 864,273 14,172 1.64 % 425,219 8,999 2.12 % Fed funds sold 7,313 192 2.63 % — — — % — — — % Loans held for sale 24,497 855 3.49 % 65,968 1,494 2.26 % 79,201 1,948 2.46 % Loans Commercial: Commercial and industrial 507,040 26,004 5.13 % 579,002 28,445 4.91 % 687,266 31,600 4.60 % Real estate construction 63,296 3,300 5.21 % 41,751 1,712 4.10 % 32,804 1,488 4.54 % Commercial real estate 713,102 29,632 4.16 % 571,326 21,523 3.77 % 523,219 21,884 4.18 % Total commercial 1,283,438 58,936 4.59 % 1,192,079 51,680 4.34 % 1,243,289 54,972 4.42 % Consumer Residential real estate first mortgage 587,443 20,573 3.50 % 477,621 16,575 3.47 % 463,174 18,391 3.97 % Residential real estate junior lien 136,483 7,222 5.29 % 131,412 6,093 4.64 % 159,844 7,696 4.81 % Other revolving and installment 52,071 2,525 4.85 % 57,574 2,537 4.41 % 79,238 3,621 4.57 % Total consumer 775,997 30,320 3.91 % 666,607 25,205 3.78 % 702,256 29,708 4.23 % Total loans (1) 2,059,435 89,256 4.33 % 1,858,686 76,885 4.14 % 1,945,545 84,680 4.35 % Federal Reserve/FHLB Stock 13,824 784 5.67 % 6,329 276 4.36 % 5,846 266 4.55 % Total interest earning assets 3,298,644 116,006 3.52 % 3,018,172 93,149 3.09 % 2,618,427 96,557 3.69 % Noninterest earning assets 202,011 160,648 156,713 Total assets $ 3,500,655 $ 3,178,820 $ 2,775,140 Interest-Bearing Liabilities Interest-bearing demand deposits $ 692,287 $ 1,516 0.22 % $ 697,276 $ 987 0.14 % $ 551,861 $ 1,624 0.29 % Money market and savings deposits 1,113,426 6,090 0.55 % 1,023,677 1,500 0.15 % 920,072 4,863 0.53 % Time deposits 221,997 1,563 0.70 % 215,624 1,174 0.54 % 203,413 2,356 1.16 % Fed funds purchased 63,296 1,554 2.46 % 3 — — % 80 — — % Short-term borrowings 89,932 2,785 3.10 % — — — % — — — % Long-term debt 58,864 2,340 3.98 % 50,759 1,897 3.74 % 58,742 3,413 5.81 % Total interest-bearing liabilities 2,239,802 15,848 0.71 % 1,987,339 5,558 0.28 % 1,734,168 12,256 0.71 % Noninterest-Bearing Liabilities and Stockholders' Equity Noninterest-bearing deposits 851,821 784,998 673,676 Other noninterest-bearing liabilities 62,677 60,424 57,088 Stockholders’ equity 346,355 346,059 310,208 Total liabilities and stockholders’ equity $ 3,500,655 $ 3,178,820 $ 2,775,140 Net interest income $ 100,158 $ 87,591 $ 84,301 Net interest rate spread 2.81 % 2.81 % 2.98 % Net interest margin on FTE basis (1) 3.04 % 2.90 % 3.22 % (1) Fully tax-equivalent adjustment was calculated utilizing a marginal income tax rate of 21.0% . 67 Table of Contents Rate/Volume Analysis The table below presents the effect of volume and rate changes on interest income and expense for the periods indicated.
Biggest changeIn these tables, adjustments are made to the yields on tax-exempt assets in order to present tax-exempt income and fully taxable income on a comparable basis. 73 Table of Contents Year ended December 31, 2023 2022 2021 Interest Average Interest Average Interest Average Average Income/ Yield/ Average Income/ Yield/ Average Income/ Yield/ (dollars in thousands) Balance Expense Rate Balance Expense Rate Balance Expense Rate Interest Earning Assets Interest-bearing deposits with banks $ 35,395 $ 1,202 3.40 % $ 58,149 $ 586 1.01 % 222,916 $ 322 0.14 % Investment securities (1) 983,545 25,199 2.56 % 1,135,426 24,333 2.14 % 864,273 14,172 1.64 % Fed funds sold — — — % 7,313 192 2.63 % — — — % Loans held for sale 13,217 721 5.46 % 24,497 855 3.49 % 65,968 1,494 2.26 % Loans Commercial: Commercial and industrial 558,458 36,986 6.62 % 507,040 26,004 5.13 % 579,002 28,445 4.91 % Real estate construction 99,315 7,607 7.66 % 63,296 3,300 5.21 % 41,751 1,712 4.10 % Commercial real estate 980,667 51,020 5.20 % 713,102 29,632 4.16 % 571,326 21,523 3.77 % Total commercial 1,638,440 95,613 5.84 % 1,283,438 58,936 4.59 % 1,192,079 51,680 4.34 % Consumer Residential real estate first mortgage 706,626 27,240 3.85 % 587,443 20,573 3.50 % 477,621 16,575 3.47 % Residential real estate junior lien 154,036 11,639 7.56 % 136,483 7,222 5.29 % 131,412 6,093 4.64 % Other revolving and installment 35,971 2,179 6.06 % 52,071 2,525 4.85 % 57,574 2,537 4.41 % Total consumer 896,633 41,058 4.58 % 775,997 30,320 3.91 % 666,607 25,205 3.78 % Total loans (1) 2,535,073 136,671 5.39 % 2,059,435 89,256 4.33 % 1,858,686 76,885 4.14 % Federal Reserve/FHLB Stock 25,246 1,761 6.98 % 13,824 784 5.67 % 6,329 276 4.36 % Total interest earning assets 3,592,476 165,554 4.61 % 3,298,644 116,006 3.52 % 3,018,172 93,149 3.09 % Cash and due from banks 30,422 31,957 27,399 Allowance for loan losses (35,883) (32,011) (34,054) Land, premises and equipment, net 17,510 17,429 19,081 Operating lease right-of-use assets 5,624 3,626 4,997 Accrued interest receivable 13,034 9,377 8,461 Bank-owned life insurance 33,059 33,573 32,760 Goodwill 46,959 39,415 30,385 Other intangible assets 19,777 21,542 23,479 Servicing rights 2,349 2,246 1,984 Deferred income taxes, net 43,443 31,593 11,685 Other assets 48,247 43,264 34,471 Noninterest earning assets 224,541 202,011 160,648 Total assets $ 3,817,017 $ 3,500,655 $ 3,178,820 Interest-Bearing Liabilities Interest-bearing demand deposits $ 768,238 $ 9,872 1.29 % $ 692,287 $ 1,516 0.22 % $ 697,276 $ 987 0.14 % Money market and savings deposits 1,118,815 32,639 2.92 % 1,113,426 6,090 0.55 % 1,023,677 1,500 0.15 % Time deposits 303,746 10,876 3.58 % 221,997 1,563 0.70 % 215,624 1,174 0.54 % Fed funds purchased 287,768 15,283 5.31 % 63,296 1,554 2.46 % 3 — — % Short-term borrowings 113,973 5,693 5.00 % 89,932 2,785 3.10 % — — — % Long-term debt 58,900 2,681 4.55 % 58,864 2,340 3.98 % 50,759 1,897 3.74 % Total interest-bearing liabilities 2,651,440 77,044 2.91 % 2,239,802 15,848 0.71 % 1,987,339 5,558 0.28 % Noninterest-Bearing Liabilities and Stockholders' Equity Noninterest-bearing deposits 737,365 851,821 784,998 Other noninterest-bearing liabilities 69,944 62,677 60,424 Stockholders’ equity 358,268 346,355 346,059 Total liabilities and stockholders’ equity $ 3,817,017 $ 3,500,655 $ 3,178,820 Net interest income $ 88,510 $ 100,158 $ 87,591 Net interest rate spread 1.70 % 2.81 % 2.81 % Net interest margin on FTE basis (1) 2.46 % 3.04 % 2.90 % (1) Fully tax-equivalent adjustment was calculated utilizing a marginal income tax rate of 21.0% . 74 Table of Contents Interest Rates and Operating Interest Differential Increases and decreases in interest income and interest expense result from changes in average balances (volume) of interest earning assets and interest-bearing liabilities, as well as changes in average interest rates.
FDIC insurance expense is also included in this line and represents the assessments that we pay to the FDIC for deposit insurance. ● Other operational expenses—includes costs related to marketing, donations, promotions, and expenses associated with office supplies, postage, travel expenses, meals and entertainment, dues and memberships, costs to maintain or prepare other real estate owned, or OREO, for sale, and other general corporate expenses that do not fit within one of the specific noninterest expense lines described above.
FDIC insurance expense is also included in this line and represents the assessments that the Company pays to the FDIC for deposit insurance. ● Other operational expenses—includes costs related to marketing, donations, promotions, and expenses associated with office supplies, postage, travel expenses, meals and entertainment, dues and memberships, 65 Table of Contents costs to maintain or prepare other real estate owned, or OREO, for sale, and other general corporate expenses that do not fit within one of the specific noninterest expense lines described above.
Summary Net income for the year ended December 31, 2022, was $40.0 million, a decrease of $12.7 million, or 24.1%, compared to $52.7 million for the year ended December 31, 2021. Diluted earnings per common share were $2.10 in 2022, compared to $2.97 in 2021. Return on average total assets was 1.14% in 2022, compared to 1.66% for 2021.
Summary Net income for the year ended December 31, 2023 was $11.7 million, a decrease of $28.3 million, or 70.8%, compared to $40.0 million for the year ended December 31, 2022. Diluted earnings per common share were $0.58 in 2023, compared to $2.10 in 2022. Return on average total assets was 0.31% in 2023, compared to 1.14% for 2022.
Selected financial information pertaining to the components of our borrowings and subordinated debt as of the dates indicated is as follows: December 31, 2022 December 31, 2021 December 31, 2020 Percent of Percent of Percent of (dollars in thousands) Balance Portfolio Balance Portfolio Balance Portfolio Fed funds purchased $ 153,080 35.0 % $ — — % $ — — % FHLB Short-term advances 225,000 51.6 % — — % — — % Subordinated notes 50,000 11.4 % 50,000 84.9 % 49,688 84.6 % Junior subordinated debentures 8,843 2.0 % 8,730 14.8 % 8,617 14.7 % Finance lease liability — — % 203 0.3 % 430 0.7 % Total borrowed funds $ 436,923 100.0 % $ 58,933 100.0 % $ 58,735 100.0 % Capital Resources The following table summarizes the changes in our stockholders’ equity for the periods indicated. For the years ended December 31, (dollars in thousands) 2022 2021 2020 Beginning balance $ 359,403 $ 330,163 $ 285,728 Net income 40,005 52,681 44,675 Other comprehensive income (loss) (94,386) (14,893) 8,702 Common stock repurchased (738) (712) (482) Common stock issued 63,830 — — Common stock dividends (13,146) (10,931) (10,387) Stock‑based compensation expense 1,904 3,095 1,927 Ending balance $ 356,872 $ 359,403 $ 330,163 Total stockholders’ equity was $356.9 million at December 31, 2022, a decrease of $2.5 million, or 0.7%, compared to $359.4 million at December 31, 2021.
Selected financial information pertaining to the components of the Company’s borrowings and subordinated debt as of the dates indicated is as follows: December 31, 2023 December 31, 2022 December 31, 2021 Percent of Percent of Percent of (dollars in thousands) Balance Portfolio Balance Portfolio Balance Portfolio Fed funds purchased $ 114,170 30.6 % $ 153,080 35.0 % $ — — % FHLB Short-term advances 200,000 53.6 % 225,000 51.6 % — — % Subordinated notes 50,000 13.4 % 50,000 11.4 % 50,000 84.9 % Junior subordinated debentures 8,956 2.4 % 8,843 2.0 % 8,730 14.8 % Finance lease liability — — % — — 203 0.3 % Total borrowed funds $ 373,126 100.0 % $ 436,923 100.0 % $ 58,933 100.0 % 91 Table of Contents Capital Resources The following table summarizes the changes in the Company’s stockholders’ equity for the periods indicated. For the years ended December 31, (dollars in thousands) 2023 2022 2021 Beginning balance $ 356,872 $ 359,403 $ 330,163 Cumulative effect of change in accounting principles, net of tax (4,452) — — Net income 11,696 40,005 52,681 Other comprehensive income (loss) 24,986 (94,386) (14,893) Common stock repurchased (6,638) (738) (712) Common stock issued — 63,830 — Common stock dividends (14,965) (13,146) (10,931) Stock‑based compensation expense 1,628 1,904 3,095 Ending balance $ 369,127 $ 356,872 $ 359,403 Total stockholders’ equity was $369.1 million at December 31, 2023, an increase of $12.3 million, or 3.4%, compared to $356.9 million at December 31, 2022.
Revenue of $67.1 million, comprised of $23.8 million in asset-based revenue and $43.4 million in participant and transaction revenues, decreased $4.6 million or 6.4% primarily due to a $4.6 billion, or 12.6%, decrease in assets under administration/management. 70 Table of Contents The following table presents changes in the combined AUA and AUM for our retirement and benefit services segment for the periods presented. Year ended December 31, (dollars in thousands) 2022 2021 2020 AUA & AUM balance beginning of period $ 36,732,938 $ 34,199,954 $ 31,904,648 Acquired assets — — 1,258,382 Inflows (1) 5,735,604 5,589,925 4,829,449 Outflows (2) (7,512,492) (6,010,136) (6,828,573) Market impact (3) (2,833,530) 2,953,195 3,036,048 AUA & AUM balance end of period $ 32,122,520 $ 36,732,938 $ 34,199,954 Yield (4) 0.20 % 0.20 % 0.18 % (1) Inflows include new account assets, contributions, dividends and interest.
Revenue of $65.3 million, comprised of $23.1 million in asset-based revenue and $42.2 million in participant and transaction revenues, decreased $1.8 million, or 2.7%, primarily due to the divestiture of the payroll services line of business. 77 Table of Contents The following table presents changes in the combined AUA and AUM for the Company’s retirement and benefit services segment for the periods presented. Year ended December 31, (dollars in thousands) 2023 2022 2021 AUA & AUM balance beginning of period $ 32,122,520 $ 36,732,938 $ 34,199,954 Acquired assets — — — Inflows (1) 4,548,845 5,735,604 5,589,925 Outflows (2) (4,836,524) (7,512,492) (6,010,136) Market impact (3) 4,847,584 (2,833,530) 2,953,195 AUA & AUM balance end of period $ 36,682,425 $ 32,122,520 $ 36,732,938 Yield (4) 0.19 % 0.20 % 0.20 % (1) Inflows include new account assets, contributions, dividends and interest.
Noninterest Expense The following table presents noninterest expense for the years ended December 31, 2022, 2021 and 2020. Year ended December 31, (dollars in thousands) 2022 2021 $ Change % Change 2021 2020 $ Change % Change Compensation $ 80,656 $ 93,386 $ (12,730) (13.6) % $ 93,386 $ 89,206 $ 4,180 4.7 % Employee taxes and benefits 21,915 22,033 (118) (0.5) % 22,033 20,050 1,983 9.9 % Occupancy and equipment expense 7,605 8,148 (543) (6.7) % 8,148 10,058 (1,910) (19.0) % Business services, software and technology expense 19,487 20,486 (999) (4.9) % 20,486 19,135 1,351 7.1 % Intangible amortization expense 4,754 4,380 374 8.5 % 4,380 3,961 419 10.6 % Professional fees and assessments 8,367 6,292 2,075 33.0 % 6,292 4,834 1,458 30.2 % Marketing and business development 3,254 3,182 72 2.3 % 3,182 3,133 49 1.6 % Supplies and postage 2,440 2,361 79 3.3 % 2,361 2,174 187 8.6 % Travel 1,182 442 740 167.4 % 442 359 83 23.1 % Mortgage and lending expenses 2,183 4,250 (2,067) (48.6) % 4,250 5,707 (1,457) (25.5) % Other 6,927 3,949 2,978 75.4 % 3,949 5,182 (1,233) (23.8) % Total noninterest expense $ 158,770 $ 168,909 $ (10,139) (6.0) % $ 168,909 $ 163,799 $ 5,110 3.1 % Total noninterest expense decreased $10.1 million, or 6.0%, to $158.8 million for the year ended December 31, 2022, from $168.9 million for 2021.
Noninterest Expense The following table presents noninterest expense for the years ended December 31, 2023, 2022 and 2021. Year ended December 31, (dollars in thousands) 2023 2022 $ Change % Change 2022 2021 $ Change % Change Compensation $ 76,290 $ 80,656 $ (4,366) (5.4) % $ 80,656 $ 93,386 $ (12,730) (13.6) % Employee taxes and benefits 20,051 21,915 (1,864) (8.5) % 21,915 22,033 (118) (0.5) % Occupancy and equipment expense 7,477 7,605 (128) (1.7) % 7,605 8,148 (543) (6.7) % Business services, software and technology expense 21,053 19,487 1,566 8.0 % 19,487 20,486 (999) (4.9) % Intangible amortization expense 5,296 4,754 542 11.4 % 4,754 4,380 374 8.5 % Professional fees and assessments 6,743 8,367 (1,624) (19.4) % 8,367 6,292 2,075 33.0 % Marketing and business development 3,027 3,254 (227) (7.0) % 3,254 3,182 72 2.3 % Supplies and postage 1,796 2,440 (644) (26.4) % 2,440 2,361 79 3.3 % Travel 1,189 1,182 7 0.6 % 1,182 442 740 167.4 % Mortgage and lending expenses 1,902 2,183 (281) (12.9) % 2,183 4,250 (2,067) (48.6) % Other 5,333 6,927 (1,594) (23.0) % 6,927 3,949 2,978 75.4 % Total noninterest expense $ 150,157 $ 158,770 $ (8,613) (5.4) % $ 158,770 $ 168,909 $ (10,139) (6.0) % Total noninterest expense decreased $8.6 million, or 5.4%, to $150.2 million for the year ended December 31, 2023, from $158.8 million for the year ended December 31, 2022.
Noninterest expense decreased $2.9 million, or 32.6%, as compared to 2021, primarily due to a decrease of allocated expenses. 71 Table of Contents The following table presents changes in the wealth management combined AUA and AUM, disaggregated by product, for the periods presented. Year ended December 31, (dollars in thousands) 2022 2021 2020 Dimension balance beginning of period $ 2,214,346 $ 1,754,647 $ 1,652,454 Inflows (1) 1,263,252 881,980 402,787 Outflows (2) (1,326,374) (623,324) (539,485) Market impact (3) (253,464) 201,043 238,891 Dimension balance end of period $ 1,897,760 $ 2,214,346 $ 1,754,647 Yield (4)(6) 0.48 % 0.51 % 0.49 % Blue Print balance beginning of period $ 716,312 $ 569,936 $ 469,937 Inflows (1) 143,355 162,537 131,436 Outflows (2) (115,458) (89,829) (83,142) Market impact (3) (108,542) 73,668 51,705 Blue Print balance end of period $ 635,667 $ 716,312 $ 569,936 Yield (4)(6) 0.98 % 0.97 % 0.92 % Trust balance beginning of period $ 279,584 $ 253,470 $ 290,677 Inflows (1) 73,446 259,790 194,897 Outflows (2) (84,668) (244,642) (251,542) Market impact (3) (16,203) 10,966 19,438 Trust balance end of period $ 252,159 $ 279,584 $ 253,470 Yield (4)(6) 0.70 % 0.64 % 0.57 % Total Wealth Management balance beginning of period $ 3,210,242 $ 2,578,053 $ 2,413,068 Inflows (1) 1,480,053 1,304,307 729,120 Outflows (2) (1,526,500) (957,795) (874,169) Market impact (3) (378,209) 285,677 310,034 Total Wealth Management balance end of period (5) $ 2,785,586 $ 3,210,242 $ 2,578,053 Yield (4)(6) 0.61 % 0.62 % 0.59 % (1) Inflows include new account assets, contributions, dividends and interest.
Noninterest expense in 2023 increased $4.1 million, or 51.3%, as compared to 2022, primarily due to an increase of allocated expenses. 78 Table of Contents The following table presents changes in the wealth management combined AUA and AUM, disaggregated by product, for the periods presented. Year ended December 31, (dollars in thousands) 2023 2022 2021 Dimension balance beginning of period $ 1,897,760 $ 2,214,346 $ 1,754,647 Inflows (1) 551,102 1,263,252 881,980 Outflows (2) (542,463) (1,326,374) (623,324) Market impact (3) 200,439 (253,464) 201,043 Dimension balance end of period $ 2,106,838 $ 1,897,760 $ 2,214,346 Yield (4)(6) 0.52 % 0.48 % 0.51 % Blue Print balance beginning of period $ 635,667 $ 716,312 $ 569,936 Inflows (1) 129,170 143,355 162,537 Outflows (2) (108,673) (115,458) (89,829) Market impact (3) 97,599 (108,542) 73,668 Blue Print balance end of period $ 753,763 $ 635,667 $ 716,312 Yield (4)(6) 1.01 % 0.98 % 0.97 % Trust balance beginning of period $ 252,159 $ 279,584 $ 253,470 Inflows (1) 88,702 73,446 259,790 Outflows (2) (85,831) (84,668) (244,642) Market impact (3) 43,420 (16,203) 10,966 Trust balance end of period $ 298,450 $ 252,159 $ 279,584 Yield (4)(6) 0.53 % 0.70 % 0.64 % Total Wealth Management balance beginning of period $ 2,785,586 $ 3,210,242 $ 2,578,053 Inflows (1) 768,974 1,480,053 1,304,307 Outflows (2) (736,967) (1,526,500) (957,795) Market impact (3) 341,458 (378,209) 285,677 Total Wealth Management balance end of period (5) $ 3,159,051 $ 2,785,586 $ 3,210,242 Yield (4)(6) 0.64 % 0.61 % 0.62 % (1) Inflows include new account assets, contributions, dividends and interest.