Biggest changeFor the Years Ended December 31, 2023 2022 Variance % of % of Amount Revenues Amount Revenues Amount % Revenues $ 21,845,830 100.0 % $ 8,818,312 100.0 % $ 13,027,518 147.7 % Cost of revenues 13,778,416 63.1 % 5,467,017 62.0 % 8,311,399 152.0 % Gross profit 8,067,414 36.9 % 3,351,295 38.0 % 4,716,119 140.7 % Operating expenses: Selling expenses 1,516,247 6.9 % 2,826,615 32.0 % (1,310,368 ) -46.4 % General and administrative expenses 9,651,381 44.2 % 6,579,734 74.6 % 3,071,647 46.7 % Research and development expenses 1,019,141 4.7 % 641,025 7.3 % 378,116 59.0 % Total operating expenses 12,186,769 55.8 % 10,047,374 113.9 % 2,139,395 21.3 % Loss from operations (4,119,355 ) -18.9 % (6,696,079 ) -75.9 % 2,576,724 -38.5 % Other income (expenses) (891,009 ) -4.0 % 12,695 0.1 % (903,704 ) -7,118.6 % Loss before income tax benefit (5,010,364 ) -22.9 % (6,683,384 ) -75.8 % 1,673,020 -25.0 % Income tax benefit (133,664 ) -0.6 % (5,918 ) -0.1 % (127,746 ) 2,158.6 % Net loss (4,876,700 ) -22.3 % (6,677,466 ) -75.7 % 1,800,766 -27.0 % Less: net loss attributable to non-controlling interest (686,810 ) -3.1 % - - (686,810 ) - 100.0 % Net loss attributable to HeartCore Enterprises, Inc. $ (4,189,890 ) -19.2 % $ (6,677,466 ) -75.7 % $ 2,487,576 -37.3 % For the Years Ended December 31, 2023 2022 Variance Amount % Amount % Amount % Revenues Revenues from on-premise software $ 1,586,218 7.3 % $ 1,860,573 21.1 % $ (274,355 ) -14.7 % Revenues from maintenance and support services 2,646,148 12.1 % 2,962,325 33.6 % (316,177 ) -10.7 % Revenues from software as a service (“SaaS”) 635,927 2.9 % 500,461 5.7 % 135,466 27.1 % Revenues from software development and other miscellaneous services 1,980,979 9.1 % 2,046,588 23.2 % (65,609 ) -3.2 % Revenues from customized software development and services 8,784,239 40.2 % - - 8,784,239 100.0 % Revenues from consulting services 6,212,319 28.4 % 1,448,365 16.4 % 4,763,954 328.9 % Total revenues 21,845,830 100.0 % 8,818,312 100.0 % 13,027,518 147.7 % Cost of revenues Costs of on-premise software 1,485,769 10.8 % 1,138,533 20.9 % 347,236 30.5 % Costs of maintenance and support services 1,024,059 7.4 % 1,159,418 21.2 % (135,359 ) -11.7 % Costs of software as a service (“SaaS”) 366,277 2.7 % 241,756 4.4 % 124,521 51.5 % Costs of software development and other miscellaneous services 1,655,461 12.0 % 2,003,127 36.6 % (347,666 ) -17.4 % Costs of customized software development and services 7,219,892 52.4 % - - 7,219,892 100.0 % Costs of consulting services 2,026,958 14.7 % 924,183 16.9 % 1,102,775 119.3 % Total cost of revenues 13,778,416 100 % 5,467,017 100.0 % 8,311,399 152.0 % Gross profit On-premise software 100,449 1 .3 % 722,040 21.5 % (621,591 ) -86.1 % Maintenance and support services 1,622,089 20.2 % 1,802,907 53.8 % (180,818 ) -10.0 % Software as a service (“SaaS”) 269,650 3.3 % 258,705 7.7 % 10,945 4.2 % Software development and other miscellaneous services 325,518 4.0 % 43,461 1.3 % 282,057 649.0 % Customized software development and services 1,564,347 19.4 % - - 1,564,347 100.0 % Consulting services 4,185,361 51.8 % 524,182 15.7 % 3,661,179 698.5 % Total gross profit $ 8,067,414 100.0 % $ 3,351,295 100.0 % $ 4,716,119 140.7 % 74 Revenues Our total revenues increased by $13,027,518, or 147.7%, to $21,845,830 for the year ended December 31, 2023 from $8,818,312 for the year ended December 31, 2022, mainly attributable to (i) the increased revenue of $4,763,954 from GO IPO consulting services as the Company obtained more IPO consulting customers in 2023 and received warrants from its customers as noncash consideration from consulting services; (ii) the increased revenue of $8,784,239 from customized software development and services as a result of acquisition of Sigmaways and its subsidiaries on February 1, 2023; offset by (iii) the decrease of $274,355 in revenue from sales of on-premise software, primarily due to the weak performance of a significant distributor and approximately 8% depreciation of Yen in the current period; and (iv) the decrease of $316,177 in revenue from maintenance and support services, as some clients canceled their maintenance service contracts, and approximately 8% depreciation of Yen.
Biggest changeFor the Years Ended December 31, 2024 2023 Variance % of % of Amount Revenues Amount Revenues Amount % Revenues $ 30,407,229 100.0 % $ 21,845,830 100.0 % $ 8,561,399 39.2 % Cost of revenues 12,579,359 41.4 % 13,778,416 63.1 % (1,199,057 ) -8.7 % Gross profit 17,827,870 58.6 % 8,067,414 36.9 % 9,760,456 121.0 % Operating expenses: Selling expenses 1,255,368 4.1 % 1,516,247 6.9 % (260,879 ) -17.2 % General and administrative expenses 8,623,587 28.4 % 9,651,381 44.2 % (1,027,794 ) -10.6 % Research and development expenses 729,584 2.4 % 1,019,141 4.7 % (289,557 ) -28.4 % Impairment of intangible asset 3,878,125 12.8 % - - 3,878,125 100.0 % Impairment of goodwill 3,276,441 10.7 % - - 3,276,441 100.0 % Total operating expenses 17,763,105 58.4 % 12,186,769 55.8 % 5,576,336 45.8 % Income (loss) from operations 64,765 0.2 % (4,119,355 ) -18.9 % 4,184,120 -101.6 % Other expenses (5,414,487 ) -17.8 % (891,009 ) -4.0 % (4,523,478 ) 507.7 % Loss before income tax benefit (5,349,722 ) -17.6 % (5,010,364 ) -22.9 % (339,358 ) 6.8 % Income tax benefit (136,822 ) -0.5 % (133,664 ) -0.6 % (3,158 ) 2.4 % Net loss (5,212,900 ) -17.1 % (4,876,700 ) -22.3 % (336,200 ) 6.9 % Less: net loss attributable to non-controlling interests (3,731,526 ) -12.2 % (686,810 ) -3.1 % (3,044,716 ) 443.3 % Net loss attributable to HeartCore Enterprises, Inc. $ (1,481,374 ) -4.9 % $ (4,189,890 ) -19.2 % $ 2,708,516 -64.6 % 70 For the Years Ended December 31, 2024 2023 Variance Amount % Amount % Amount % Revenues Revenues from on-premise software $ 2,700,769 8.9 % $ 1,586,218 7.3 % $ 1,114,551 70.3 % Revenues from maintenance and support services 2,625,992 8.6 % 2,646,148 12.1 % (20,156 ) -0.8 % Revenues from software as a service (“SaaS”) 564,292 1.9 % 635,927 2.9 % (71,635 ) -11.3 % Revenues from software development and other miscellaneous services 1,925,117 6.3 % 1,980,979 9.1 % (55,862 ) -2.8 % Revenues from customized software development and services 7,854,285 25.8 % 8,784,239 40.2 % (929,954 ) -10.6 % Revenues from consulting services 14,736,774 48.5 % 6,212,319 28.4 % 8,524,455 137.2 % Total revenues 30,407,229 100.0 % 21,845,830 100.0 % 8,561,399 39.2 % Cost of revenues Costs of on-premise software 1,608,105 12.8 % 1,485,769 10.8 % 122,336 8.2 % Costs of maintenance and support services 692,026 5.5 % 1,024,059 7.4 % (332,033 ) -32.4 % Costs of software as a service (“SaaS”) 415,835 3.3 % 366,277 2.7 % 49,558 13.5 % Costs of software development and other miscellaneous services 1,635,953 13.0 % 1,655,461 12.0 % (19,508 ) -1.2 % Costs of customized software development and services 7,285,674 57.9 % 7,219,892 52.4 % 65,782 0.9 % Costs of consulting services 941,766 7.5 % 2,026,958 14.7 % (1,085,192 ) -53.5 % Total cost of revenues 12,579,359 100.0 % 13,778,416 100.0 % (1,199,057 ) -8.7 % Gross profit On-premise software 1,092,664 6.2 % 100,449 1.3 % 992,215 987.8 % Maintenance and support services 1,933,966 10.8 % 1,622,089 20.2 % 311,877 19.2 % Software as a service (“SaaS”) 148,457 0.8 % 269,650 3.3 % (121,193 ) -44.9 % Software development and other miscellaneous services 289,164 1.6 % 325,518 4.0 % (36,354 ) -11.2 % Customized software development and services 568,611 3.2 % 1,564,347 19.4 % (995,736 ) -63.7 % Consulting services 13,795,008 77.4 % 4,185,361 51.8 % 9,609,647 229.6 % Total gross profit $ 17,827,870 100.0 % $ 8,067,414 100.0 % $ 9,760,456 121.0 % 71 Revenues Our total revenues increased by $8,561,399, or 39.2%, to $30,407,229 for the year ended December 31, 2024 from $21,845,830 for the year ended December 31, 2023, mainly attributable to (i) the increased revenue of $8,524,455 from GO IPO consulting services as two of the Company’s GO IPO consulting customers successfully listed on the Nasdaq in the fiscal year 2024 and the Company recognized revenues from noncash consideration in the form of warrants and ordinary shares from the consulting services customers of $13.5 million, while only $3.8 million of revenue recognized from noncash consideration in the form of warrants in the fiscal year 2023; and (ii) an increase of $1,114,551 in on-premise software revenue as we entered into multiple long-term license contracts with relatively large contract price and revenue amount in the fiscal year 2024; and offset by (iii) a decrease of $929,954 in revenue from customized software development and services due to intense market competition and we obtained fewer customer orders in the fiscal year 2024.
For the reasons discussed above, our overall gross profit margin decreased by 1.1% to 36.9% for the year ended December 31, 2023 from 38.0% in the fiscal year 2022. 75 Operating Expenses The following table sets forth the breakdown of our operating expenses for the fiscal years ended December 31, 2023 and 2022: For the Years Ended December 31, 2023 2022 Variance % of % of Amount Revenues Amount Revenues Amount % of Total revenues $ 21,845,830 100.0 % $ 8,818,312 100.0 % $ 13,027,518 147.7 % Operating expenses: Selling expenses 1,516,247 6.9 % 2,826,615 32.0 % (1,310,368 ) -46.4 % General and administrative expenses 9,651,381 44.2 % 6,579,734 74.6 % 3,071,647 46.7 % Research and development expenses 1,019,141 4.7 % 641,025 7.3 % 378,116 59.0 % Total operating expenses $ 12,186,769 55.8 % $ 10,047,374 113.9 % $ 2,139,395 21.3 % Selling Expenses Our selling expenses primarily include advertising expenses, sales commissions, sales promotion expenses, and stock-based compensation.
For the reasons discussed above, our overall gross profit margin increased by 21.7% to 58.6% for the year ended December 31, 2024 from 36.9% in the fiscal year 2023. 72 Operating Expenses The following table sets forth the breakdown of our operating expenses for the fiscal years ended December 31, 2024 and 2023: For the Years Ended December 31, 2024 2023 Variance % of % of Amount Revenues Amount Revenues Amount % of Total revenues $ 30,407,229 100.0 % $ 21,845,830 100.0 % $ 8,561,399 39.2 % Operating expenses: Selling expenses 1,255,368 4.1 % 1,516,247 6.9 % (260,879 ) -17.2 % General and administrative expenses 8,623,587 28.4 % 9,651,381 44.2 % (1,027,794 ) -10.6 % Research and development expenses 729,584 2.4 % 1,019,141 4.7 % (289,557 ) -28.4 % Impairment of intangible asset 3,878,125 12.8 % - - 3,878,125 100.0 % Impairment of goodwill 3,276,441 10.7 % - - 3,276,441 100.0 % Total operating expenses $ 17,763,105 58.4 % $ 12,186,769 55.8 % $ 5,576,336 45.8 % Selling Expenses Our selling expenses primarily include advertising expenses, sales salaries, commissions, and welfare, sales promotion expenses, referral expense, and stock-based compensation.
For the fiscal years ended December 31, 2023 and 2022, we generated revenues of $21,845,830 and $8,818,312, respectively, and reported net loss of $4,876,700 and $6,677,466, respectively, and cash flows used in operating activities of $4,331,209 and $4,808,547, respectively. As noted in our consolidated financial statements, as of December 31, 2023, we had an accumulated deficit of $14,763,469.
In April 2024, HeartCore Financial incorporated a branch office, HeartCore Financial, Inc. – Japan Branch Office, in Japan. For the fiscal years ended December 31, 2024 and 2023, we generated revenues of $30,407,229 and $21,845,830, respectively, and reported net loss of $5,212,900 and $4,876,700, respectively, and cash flows used in operating activities of $4,774,971 and $4,331,209, respectively.
For the Years Ended December 31, 2023 2022 Variance Amount % of Amount % of Amount % of Research and development expenses Salaries and welfare expenses $ - - $ 29,681 4.6 % $ (29,681 ) -100.0 % Outsourcing expenses 958,830 94.1 % 601,583 93.9 % 357,247 59.4 % Stock-based compensation 60,311 5.9 % 9,761 1.5 % 50,550 517.9 % Total research and development expenses $ 1,019,141 100.0 % $ 641,025 100.0 % $ 378,116 59.0 % Our research and development expenses increased by $378,116 or 59.0%, to $1,019,141 in the fiscal year ended December 31, 2023 from $641,025 in the fiscal year ended December 31, 2022, primarily attributable to an increase of $357,247 in outsourcing expenses relating to the development of new CMS management screen features in the current period and additional R&D expenses incurred by Sigmaways to support its customized software development and services .
For the Years Ended December 31, 2024 2023 Variance Amount % Amount % Amount % Research and development expenses Salaries and welfare expenses $ 371,748 51.0 % $ - - $ 371,748 100.0 % Outsourcing expenses 355,463 48.7 % 958,830 94.1 % (603,367 ) -62.9 % Stock-based compensation 2,373 0.3 % 60,311 5.9 % (57,938 ) -96.1 % Total research and development expenses $ 729,584 100.0 % $ 1,019,141 100.0 % $ (289,557 ) -28.4 % Our research and development expenses decreased by $289,557 or 28.4%, to $729,584 in the year ended December 31, 2024 from $1,019,141 in the year ended December 31, 2023, primarily attributable to a decrease of $603,367 in outsourcing expenses relating to the development of new CMS management screen features, which stared in 2023 and about to completed in the current year; and offset by an increase of $371,748 in salaries and welfare expenses for the employees assigned to the development of a new product, Global CMS, started in 2024.
Total other expenses, net, increased by $903,704 or 7,118.6%, from other income, net, of $12,695 for the year ended December 31, 2022 to other expenses, net, of $891,009 for the year ended December 31, 2023, primarily attributable to an increase of $615,520 in loss on fair value changes in investments in marketable securities and an increase of $501,445 in loss on fair value changes in investment in warrants, offset by an increase of $309,015 in other income, primarily due to the penalty payment that we received from certain customers in the current period.
Total other expenses, net, increased by $4,523,478 or 507.7%, from other expenses, net, of $891,009 for the year ended December 31, 2023 to other expenses, net, of $5,414,487 for the year ended December 31, 2024, primarily attributable to an increase of $1,796,865 in loss on fair value changes in investments in marketable securities, an increase of $3,970,628 in loss on sale of warrants, and an increase of $300,000 in impairment of investment in equity securities, offset by an increase of $2,159,144 in gain on fair value changes in investment in warrants.
In assessing our liquidity, management monitors and analyzes our cash, our ability to generate sufficient revenues in the future, and our operating and capital expenditure commitments. 78 Cash Flows for the Years Ended December 31, 2023 and 2022 The following table sets forth summary of our cash flows for the periods indicated: For the Years Ended December 31, 2023 2022 Net cash used in operating activities $ (4,331,209 ) $ (4,808,547 ) Net cash used in investing activities (1,780,952 ) (12,200 ) Net cash provided by financing activities 136,194 8,915,341 Effect of exchange rate changes (188,880 ) (54,107 ) Net change in cash and cash equivalents (6,164,847 ) 4,040,487 Cash and cash equivalents, beginning of the year 7,177,326 3,136,839 Cash and cash equivalents, end of the year $ 1,012,479 $ 7,177,326 Operating Activities Net cash used in operating activities was $4,331,209 for the year ended December 31, 2023, primarily consisting of the following: ● Net loss of $4,876,700 for the fiscal year. ● Warrants received as non-cash consideration of $3,763,621 as our IPO consulting customers completed the IPO during the current period. ● An increase in accounts receivable of $338,312.
Cash Flows for the Years Ended December 31, 2024 and 2023 The following table sets forth summary of our cash flows for the periods indicated: For the Years Ended December 31, 2024 2023 Net cash used in operating activities $ (4,774,971 ) $ (4,331,209 ) Net cash provided by (used in) investing activities 6,349,204 (1,780,952 ) Net cash provided by (used in) financing activities (318,646 ) 136,194 Effect of exchange rate changes (146,977 ) (188,880 ) Net change in cash and cash equivalents 1,108,610 (6,164,847 ) Cash and cash equivalents, beginning of the year 1,012,479 7,177,326 Cash and cash equivalents, end of the year $ 2,121,089 $ 1,012,479 Operating Activities Net cash used in operating activities was $4,774,971 for the year ended December 31, 2024, primarily consisting of the following: ● Net loss of $5,212,900 for the fiscal year. ● Marketable securities and warrants received as noncash consideration in total of $13,541,693 as two of our IPO consulting customers completed the IPO during the current year. ● A deferred income tax benefits of $1,076,600 mainly brought by amortization and impairment of intangible asset. ● A gain of $1,657,699 on fair value changes in investment in warrants. ● Offset by loss of $3,970,628 recognized on sale of warrants to a third party. ● Offset by a total of $7,154,566 loss recognized on impairment of goodwill and intangible asset acquired from business acquisition of Sigmaways and its subsidiaries. ● Offset by a loss of $2,412,385 on fair value changes in investments in marketable securities. ● Offset by depreciation and amortization expenses of $749,639. ● Offset by an increase of $669,142 in income tax payable. ● Offset by an increase of $710,001 in other liabilities, mainly because the increase of liability to refund a customer. 76 Net cash used in operating activities was $4,331,209 for the year ended December 31, 2023, primarily consisting of the following: ● Net loss of $4,876,700 for the fiscal year. ● Warrants received as non-cash consideration of $3,763,621 as our IPO consulting customers completed the IPO during the current year. ● An increase in accounts receivable of $338,312.
Financing Activities Net cash provided by financing activities amounted to $136,194 for the fiscal year ended December 31, 2023, primarily consisted of proceeds of $710,107 from short-term and long-term debts, and net proceeds of $562,767 from factoring arrangement, offset by repayment of $711,395 for long-term debts, and repayment of 389,035 for insurance premium financing. 79 Net cash provided by financing activities amounted to $8,915,341 for the fiscal year ended December 31, 2022, primarily consisting of proceeds of $13,823,126 from the initial public offering and issuance of common shares prior to the initial public offering, proceeds of $258,087 from long-term debt, offset by payment for mandatorily redeemable financial interest of $430,489, payment for repurchase of common shares of $3,500,000, repayment of long-term debts of $810,750, and repayment of insurance premium financing of $388,538.
Net cash provided by financing activities amounted to $136,194 for the fiscal year ended December 31, 2023, primarily consisted of proceeds of $710,107 from short-term and long-term debts, and net proceeds of $562,767 from factoring arrangement, offset by repayment of $711,395 for long-term debts, and repayment of 389,035 for insurance premium financing. 77 Contractual Obligations Lease Commitment The Company has entered into operating leases for office space with terms ranging from two to fifteen years, and finance leases for office equipment and vehicle with terms of five years.
As a percentage of revenues, research and development expenses were 4.7% and 7.3% of our revenues for the fiscal years ended December 31, 2023 and 2022, respectively. 77 Other Income (Expenses), Net Our other income (expenses) primarily includes changes in fair value of investments in marketable securities, changes in fair value of investment in warrants, interest income generated from bank deposits, interest expense for bank loans, bonds, and leases, government grants, other income, and other expenses.
As of December 31, 2024, we evaluated the fair value of the reporting unit of Sigmaways and its subsidiaries and estimated the value of goodwill become zero by engaging a third-party valuation appraiser, accordingly, we recorded an impairment of goodwill of $3,276,441 in the year ended December 31, 2024. 74 Other Income (Expenses), Net Our other income (expenses) primarily includes changes in fair value of investments in marketable securities, changes in fair value of investment in warrants, loss on sale of warrants, interest income generated from bank deposits, interest expenses for bank loans and bonds, government grants, impairment of investment in equity securities, loss on forgiveness of note receivable, other income, and other expenses.
As of December 31, 2023, future minimum lease payments under the non-cancelable lease agreements are as follows: Year Ended December 31, Finance Leases Operating Leases 2024 $ 18,819 $ 427,774 2025 18,555 404,244 2026 18,555 339,188 2027 18,555 292,720 2028 12,370 292,720 Thereafter - 912,521 Total lease payments 86,854 2,669,167 Less: imputed interest (2,630 ) (137,472 ) Total lease liabilities 84,224 2,531,695 Less: current portion (17,445 ) (396,535 ) Non-current lease liabilities $ 66,779 $ 2,135,160 80 Debt s The Company’s debts included short-term debt and long-term debts borrowed from banks and other financial institutions.
As of December 31, 2024, future minimum lease payments under the non-cancelable lease agreements are as follows: Year Ended December 31, Finance Lease Operating Leases 2025 $ 16,640 $ 394,538 2026 16,640 301,182 2027 16,640 259,508 2028 11,093 259,508 2029 - 259,508 Thereafter - 603,091 Total lease payments 61,013 2,077,335 Less: imputed interest (1,464 ) (90,388 ) Total lease liabilities 59,549 1,986,947 Less: current portion (15,956 ) (371,951 ) Non-current lease liabilities $ 43,593 $ 1,614,996 Debt s The Company’s debts included long-term debts borrowed from banks and financial institutions.
For the Years Ended December 31, 2023 2022 Variance Amount % of Amount % of Amount % of Selling expenses Advertising expenses $ 832,491 54.9 % $ 1,902,942 67.3 % $ (1,070,451 ) -56.3 % Sales commissions 119,736 7.9 % 122,797 4.3 % (3,061 ) -2.5 % Sales promotion expenses 2,931 0.2 % 16,017 0.6 % (13,086 ) -81.7 % Stock-based compensation 561,089 37.0 % 784,859 27.8 % (223,770 ) -28.5 % Total selling expenses $ 1,516,247 100.0 % $ 2,826,615 100.0 % $ (1,310,368 ) -46.4 % Our selling expenses decreased by $1,310,368, or 46.4%, to $1,516,247 for the year ended December 31, 2023 from $2,826,615 in the fiscal year 2022, primarily attributable to a decrease of $1,070,451 in advertising expenses, as the Company spent heavily on investor relations and public relations in the U.S. immediately after listing in Nasdaq in early 2022, and a decrease of $223,770 in stock-based compensation, as the Company granted stock options to certain sales staff in 2022, who were promoted to executive management in 2023, therefore the corresponding stock-based compensation was classified to general and administrative expenses.
For the Years Ended December 31, 2024 2023 Variance Amount % Amount % Amount % Selling expenses Advertising expenses $ 473,132 37.7 % $ 832,491 54.9 % $ (359,359 ) -43.2 % Sales salaries, commissions and welfare 584,699 46.6 % 119,736 7.9 % 464,963 388.3 % Sales promotion expenses 2,924 0.2 % 2,931 0.2 % (7 ) -0.2 % Referral expenses 50,000 4.0 % - - 50,000 100.0 % Stock-based compensation 144,613 11.5 % 561,089 37.0 % (416,476 ) -74.2 % Total selling expenses $ 1,255,368 100.0 % $ 1,516,247 100.0 % $ (260,879 ) -17.2 % Our selling expenses decreased by $260,879, or 17.2%, to $1,255,368 for the year ended December 31, 2024 from $1,516,247 in the fiscal year 2023, primarily attributable to (i) a decrease of $359,359 in advertising expenses due to less advertising activities in the current year, (ii) a decrease of $416,476 in stock-based compensation, as the Company granted restricted common stocks which immediately vested upon issuance and stock options to employees of Sigmaways in 2023, and there was no such amount restricted common stocks and stock options granted in the current year, the decrease is also contributed by the graded vesting method of stock options for those issued in previous years, which generally more stock-based compensation will recognize in the early stage, offset by (iii) the increase of $464,963 in sales salaries, commissions and welfare as the Company shifted marketing strategy in the fiscal year 2024.