Biggest changeThe Factoring segment includes only factoring originated by Triumph Financial Services. 68 Table of Contents The following tables present our primary operating results for our operating segments: (Dollars in thousands) Year Ended December 31, 2022 Banking Factoring Payments Corporate Consolidated Total interest income $ 195,871 $ 207,114 $ 16,079 $ 175 $ 419,239 Intersegment interest allocations 9,567 (9,444) (123) — — Total interest expense 10,873 — — 7,874 18,747 Net interest income (expense) 194,565 197,670 15,956 (7,699) 400,492 Credit loss expense (benefit) 2,753 2,895 218 1,059 6,925 Net interest income after credit loss expense 191,812 194,775 15,738 (8,758) 393,567 Noninterest income 41,096 22,272 20,620 80 84,068 Noninterest expense 186,770 87,197 63,231 3,433 340,631 Operating income (loss) $ 46,138 $ 129,850 $ (26,873) $ (12,111) $ 137,004 (Dollars in thousands) Year Ended December 31, 2021 Banking Factoring Payments Corporate Consolidated Total interest income $ 189,621 $ 185,741 $ 12,093 $ 100 $ 387,555 Intersegment interest allocations 10,389 (9,878) (511) — — Total interest expense 10,205 — — 8,220 18,425 Net interest income (expense) 189,805 175,863 11,582 (8,120) 369,130 Credit loss expense (benefit) (19,016) 9,691 438 57 (8,830) Net interest income after credit loss expense 208,821 166,172 11,144 (8,177) 377,960 Noninterest income 33,447 13,005 7,451 598 54,501 Noninterest expense 169,114 74,768 39,769 3,856 287,507 Operating income (loss) $ 73,154 $ 104,409 $ (21,174) $ (11,435) $ 144,954 (Dollars in thousands) Year Ended December 31, 2020 Banking Factoring Payments Corporate Consolidated Total interest income $ 207,978 $ 109,391 $ 4,474 $ 272 $ 322,115 Intersegment interest allocations 12,815 (12,371) (444) — — Total interest expense 29,910 — — 7,477 37,387 Net interest income (expense) 190,883 97,020 4,030 (7,205) 284,728 Credit loss expense (benefit) 20,217 16,042 172 1,898 38,329 Net interest income after credit loss expense 170,666 80,978 3,858 (9,103) 246,399 Gain on sale of subsidiary or division 9,758 — — — 9,758 Other noninterest income 29,379 21,010 125 113 50,627 Noninterest expense 151,115 54,011 12,880 4,068 222,074 Operating income (loss) $ 58,688 $ 47,977 $ (8,897) $ (13,058) $ 84,710 (Dollars in thousands) December 31, 2022 Banking Factoring Payments Corporate Eliminations Consolidated Total assets $ 4,931,666 $ 1,250,476 $ 371,948 $ 1,040,175 $ (2,260,482) $ 5,333,783 Gross loans $ 3,576,216 $ 1,151,727 $ 85,722 $ — $ (693,374) $ 4,120,291 (Dollars in thousands) December 31, 2021 Banking Factoring Payments Corporate Eliminations Consolidated Total assets $ 5,568,826 $ 1,679,495 $ 293,212 $ 1,009,998 $ (2,595,281) $ 5,956,250 Gross loans $ 4,444,136 $ 1,546,361 $ 153,176 $ 700 $ (1,276,801) $ 4,867,572 69 Table of Contents Banking (Dollars in thousands) Years Ended December 31, 2022 Compared to 2021 2021 Compared to 2020 Banking 2022 2021 2020 $ Change % Change $ Change % Change Total interest income $ 195,871 $ 189,621 $ 207,978 $ 6,250 3.3 % $ (18,357) (8.8) % Intersegment interest allocations 9,567 10,389 12,815 (822) (7.9 %) (2,426) (18.9) % Total interest expense 10,873 10,205 29,910 668 6.5 % (19,705) (65.9) % Net interest income (expense) 194,565 189,805 190,883 4,760 2.5 % (1,078) (0.6) % Credit loss expense (benefit) 2,753 (19,016) 20,217 21,769 114.5 % (39,233) (194.1) % Net interest income (expense) after credit loss expense 191,812 208,821 170,666 (17,009) (8.1) % 38,155 22.4 % Gain on sale of subsidiary or division — — 9,758 — — % (9,758) (100.0) % Other noninterest income 41,096 33,447 29,379 7,649 22.9 % 4,068 13.8 % Noninterest expense 186,770 169,114 151,115 17,656 10.4 % 17,999 11.9 % Operating income (loss) $ 46,138 $ 73,154 $ 58,688 $ (27,016) (36.9 %) $ 14,466 24.6 % Our Banking segment’s operating income decreased $27.0 million, or 36.9%.
Biggest changeTaxes are paid on a consolidated basis and are not allocated for segment purposes. 70 Table of Contents The following tables present our primary operating results for our operating segments: (Dollars in thousands) Year Ended December 31, 2023 Banking Factoring Payments Corporate Consolidated Total interest income $ 261,639 $ 144,217 $ 16,390 $ 175 $ 422,421 Intersegment interest allocations 31,450 (38,157) 6,707 — — Total interest expense 44,640 — — 9,702 54,342 Net interest income (expense) 248,449 106,060 23,097 (9,527) 368,079 Credit loss expense (benefit) 8,498 2,900 60 745 12,203 Net interest income after credit loss expense 239,951 103,160 23,037 (10,272) 355,876 Noninterest income 23,964 7,829 18,087 293 50,173 Noninterest expense 127,713 79,612 61,695 84,214 353,234 Net intersegment noninterest income (expense) (1) — 123 (123) — — Net income (loss) before income tax expense $ 136,202 $ 31,500 $ (20,694) $ (94,193) $ 52,815 (Dollars in thousands) Year Ended December 31, 2022 Banking Factoring Payments Corporate Consolidated Total interest income $ 195,871 $ 207,114 $ 16,079 $ 175 $ 419,239 Intersegment interest allocations 19,912 (19,382) (530) — — Total interest expense 10,874 — — 7,873 18,747 Net interest income (expense) 204,909 187,732 15,549 (7,698) 400,492 Credit loss expense (benefit) 2,753 2,895 218 1,059 6,925 Net interest income after credit loss expense 202,156 184,837 15,331 (8,757) 393,567 Noninterest income 40,984 22,272 20,620 192 84,068 Noninterest expense 121,916 91,673 63,231 63,811 340,631 Net intersegment noninterest income (expense) — — — — — Net income (loss) before income tax expense $ 121,224 $ 115,436 $ (27,280) $ (72,376) $ 137,004 (Dollars in thousands) Year Ended December 31, 2021 Banking Factoring Payments Corporate Consolidated Total interest income $ 189,621 $ 185,741 $ 12,093 $ 100 $ 387,555 Intersegment interest allocations 1,132 (1,057) (75) — — Total interest expense 10,205 — — 8,220 18,425 Net interest income (expense) 180,548 184,684 12,018 (8,120) 369,130 Credit loss expense (benefit) (19,016) 9,691 438 57 (8,830) Net interest income after credit loss expense 199,564 174,993 11,580 (8,177) 377,960 Noninterest income 33,374 13,005 7,451 671 54,501 Noninterest expense 121,325 74,928 39,768 51,486 287,507 Net intersegment noninterest income (expense) — — — — — Net income (loss) before income tax expense $ 111,613 $ 113,070 $ (20,737) $ (58,992) $ 144,954 (1) Net intersegment noninterest income (expense) includes: (Dollars in thousands) Factoring Payments Year Ended December 31, 2023 Factoring revenue received from Payments $ 1,190 $ (1,190) Payments revenue received from Factoring (1,067) 1,067 Net intersegment noninterest income (expense) $ 123 $ (123) 71 Table of Contents (Dollars in thousands) December 31, 2023 Banking Factoring Payments Corporate Eliminations Consolidated Total assets $ 4,918,527 $ 1,077,367 $ 546,985 $ 1,056,646 $ (2,252,191) $ 5,347,334 Gross loans $ 3,595,527 $ 941,926 $ 174,728 $ — $ (549,081) $ 4,163,100 (Dollars in thousands) December 31, 2022 Banking Factoring Payments Corporate Eliminations Consolidated Total assets $ 4,910,628 $ 1,260,209 $ 371,948 $ 1,061,662 $ (2,270,664) $ 5,333,783 Gross loans $ 3,572,716 $ 1,151,727 $ 85,722 $ — $ (689,874) $ 4,120,291 Banking (Dollars in thousands) Years Ended December 31, 2023 Compared to 2022 2022 Compared to 2021 Banking 2023 2022 2021 $ Change % Change $ Change % Change Total interest income $ 261,639 $ 195,871 $ 189,621 $ 65,768 33.6 % $ 6,250 3.3 % Intersegment interest allocations 31,450 19,912 1,132 11,538 57.9 % 18,780 1,659.0 % Total interest expense 44,640 10,874 10,205 33,766 310.5 % 669 6.6 % Net interest income (expense) 248,449 204,909 180,548 43,540 21.2 % 24,361 13.5 % Credit loss expense (benefit) 8,498 2,753 (19,016) 5,745 208.7 % 21,769 114.5 % Net interest income (expense) after credit loss expense 239,951 202,156 199,564 37,795 18.7 % 2,592 1.3 % Noninterest income 23,964 40,984 33,374 (17,020) (41.5) % 7,610 22.8 % Noninterest expense 127,713 121,916 121,325 5,797 4.8 % 591 0.5 % Net intersegment noninterest income (expense) — — — — — % — — % Net income (loss) before income tax expense $ 136,202 $ 121,224 $ 111,613 $ 14,978 12.4 % $ 9,611 8.6 % Our Banking segment’s operating income increased $15.0 million, or 12.4%.
There are or will be important factors that could cause our actual results to differ materially from those indicated in these forward-looking statements, including, but not limited to, the following: • business and economic conditions generally and in the bank and non-bank financial services industries, nationally and within our local market areas; • our ability to mitigate our risk exposures; • our ability to maintain our historical earnings trends; • changes in management personnel; • interest rate risk; • concentration of our products and services in the transportation industry; • credit risk associated with our loan portfolio; • lack of seasoning in our loan portfolio; 50 Table of Contents • deteriorating asset quality and higher loan charge-offs; • time and effort necessary to resolve nonperforming assets; • inaccuracy of the assumptions and estimates we make in establishing reserves for probable loan losses and other estimates; • risks related to the integration of acquired businesses and any future acquisitions; • our ability to successfully identify and address the risks associated with our possible future acquisitions, and the risks that our prior and possible future acquisitions make it more difficult for investors to evaluate our business, financial condition and results of operations, and impairs our ability to accurately forecast our future performance; • lack of liquidity; • fluctuations in the fair value and liquidity of the securities we hold for sale; • impairment of investment securities, goodwill, other intangible assets or deferred tax assets; • our risk management strategies; • environmental liability associated with our lending activities; • increased competition in the bank and non-bank financial services industries, nationally, regionally or locally, which may adversely affect pricing and terms; • the accuracy of our financial statements and related disclosures; • material weaknesses in our internal control over financial reporting; • system failures or failures to prevent breaches of our network security; • the institution and outcome of litigation and other legal proceedings against us or to which we become subject; • changes in carry-forwards of net operating losses; • changes in federal tax law or policy; • the impact of recent and future legislative and regulatory changes, including changes in banking, securities and tax laws and regulations, such as the Dodd-Frank Act and their application by our regulators; • governmental monetary and fiscal policies; • changes in the scope and cost of FDIC, insurance and other coverages; • failure to receive regulatory approval for future acquisitions; • increases in our capital requirements and; • the impact of COVID-19 on our business.
There are or will be important factors that could cause our actual results to differ materially from those indicated in these forward-looking statements, including, but not limited to, the following: • business and economic conditions generally and in the bank and non-bank financial services industries, nationally and within our local market areas; • our ability to mitigate our risk exposures; • our ability to maintain our historical earnings trends; • changes in management personnel; • interest rate risk; • concentration of our products and services in the transportation industry; • credit risk associated with our loan portfolio; • lack of seasoning in our loan portfolio; • deteriorating asset quality and higher loan charge-offs; • time and effort necessary to resolve nonperforming assets; • inaccuracy of the assumptions and estimates we make in establishing reserves for probable loan losses and other estimates; • risks related to the integration of acquired businesses and any future acquisitions; • our ability to successfully identify and address the risks associated with our possible future acquisitions, and the risks that our prior and possible future acquisitions make it more difficult for investors to evaluate our business, financial condition and results of operations, and impairs our ability to accurately forecast our future performance; • lack of liquidity; • fluctuations in the fair value and liquidity of the securities we hold for sale; • impairment of investment securities, goodwill, other intangible assets or deferred tax assets; • our risk management strategies; • environmental liability associated with our lending activities; • increased competition in the bank and non-bank financial services industries, nationally, regionally or locally, which may adversely affect pricing and terms; • the accuracy of our financial statements and related disclosures; • material weaknesses in our internal control over financial reporting; • system failures or failures to prevent breaches of our network security; • the institution and outcome of litigation and other legal proceedings against us or to which we become subject; • changes in carry-forwards of net operating losses; • changes in federal tax law or policy; 52 Table of Contents • the impact of recent and future legislative and regulatory changes, including changes in banking, securities and tax laws and regulations, such as the Dodd-Frank Act and their application by our regulators; • governmental monetary and fiscal policies; • changes in the scope and cost of FDIC, insurance and other coverages; • failure to receive regulatory approval for future acquisitions and; • increases in our capital requirements.
The following table provides a summary of our FHLB borrowings as of and for the years ended December 31, 2022, 2021, and 2020: (Dollars in thousands) December 31, 2022 December 31, 2021 December 31, 2020 Amount outstanding at end of the year $ 30,000 $ 180,000 $ 105,000 Weighted average interest rate at end of the year 4.25 % 0.15 % 0.17 % Average daily balance during the year $ 69,658 $ 37,671 $ 342,264 Weighted average interest rate during the year 1.19 % 0.24 % 0.58 % Maximum month-end balance during the year $ 230,000 $ 180,000 $ 850,000 Our FHLB advances are collateralized by assets, including a blanket pledge of certain loans.
The following table provides a summary of our FHLB borrowings as of and for the years ended December 31, 2023, 2022, and 2021: (Dollars in thousands) December 31, 2023 December 31, 2022 December 31, 2021 Amount outstanding at end of the year $ 255,000 $ 30,000 $ 180,000 Weighted average interest rate at end of the year 5.65 % 4.25 % 0.15 % Average daily balance during the year $ 194,795 $ 69,658 $ 37,671 Weighted average interest rate during the year 5.30 % 1.19 % 0.24 % Maximum month-end balance during the year $ 530,000 $ 230,000 $ 180,000 Our FHLB advances are collateralized by assets, including a blanket pledge of certain loans.
The following table provides information on the maturity distribution of the time deposits exceeding the FDIC insurance limit as of December 31, 2022: (Dollars in thousands) Over $250,000 Maturity 3 months or less $ 13,226 Over 3 through 6 months 14,249 Over 6 through 12 months 15,115 Over 12 months 8,622 $ 51,212 Other Borrowings Customer Repurchase Agreements The following table provides a summary of our customer repurchase agreements as of and for the years ended December 31, 2022, 2021, and 2020: (Dollars in thousands) December 31, 2022 December 31, 2021 December 31, 2020 Amount outstanding at end of period $ 340 $ 2,103 $ 3,099 Weighted average interest rate at end of period 0.03 % 0.03 % 0.03 % Average daily balance during the period $ 6,701 $ 5,985 $ 6,716 Weighted average interest rate during the period 0.03 % 0.03 % 0.03 % Maximum month-end balance during the period $ 13,463 $ 12,405 $ 14,192 Our customer repurchase agreements generally have overnight maturities.
The following table provides information on the maturity distribution of the time deposits exceeding the $250,000 FDIC insurance limit as of December 31, 2023: (Dollars in thousands) Over $250,000 Maturity 3 months or less $ 19,119 Over 3 through 6 months 10,463 Over 6 through 12 months 23,812 Over 12 months 5,028 $ 58,422 Other Borrowings Customer Repurchase Agreements The following table provides a summary of our customer repurchase agreements as of and for the years ended December 31, 2023, 2022, and 2021: (Dollars in thousands) December 31, 2023 December 31, 2022 December 31, 2021 Amount outstanding at end of period $ — $ 340 $ 2,103 Weighted average interest rate at end of period — % 0.03 % 0.03 % Average daily balance during the period $ 723 $ 6,701 $ 5,985 Weighted average interest rate during the period 0.03 % 0.03 % 0.03 % Maximum month-end balance during the period $ 3,208 $ 13,463 $ 12,405 Our customer repurchase agreements generally have overnight maturities.
Financial Highlights The following table shows selected financial data for each of the years in the three year period ended December 31, 2022: As of and for the years ended December 31, (Dollars in thousands, except per share amounts) 2022 2021 2020 Income Statement Data: Interest income $ 419,239 $ 387,555 $ 322,115 Interest expense 18,747 18,425 37,387 Net interest income 400,492 369,130 284,728 Credit loss expense (benefit) 6,925 (8,830) 38,329 Net interest income after provision 393,567 377,960 246,399 Gain on sale of subsidiary or division — — 9,758 Other noninterest income 84,068 54,501 50,627 Noninterest income 84,068 54,501 60,385 Noninterest expense 340,631 287,507 222,074 Net income before income taxes 137,004 144,954 84,710 Income tax expense 34,693 31,980 20,686 Net income 102,311 112,974 64,024 Dividends on preferred stock (3,206) (3,206) (1,701) Net income available to common stockholders $ 99,105 $ 109,768 $ 62,323 Balance Sheet Data: Total assets $ 5,333,783 $ 5,956,250 $ 5,935,791 Cash and cash equivalents 408,182 383,178 314,393 Investment securities 263,772 192,877 236,055 Loans held for sale 5,641 7,330 24,546 Loans held for investment, net 4,077,484 4,825,359 4,901,037 Total liabilities 4,444,812 5,097,386 5,209,010 Noninterest-bearing deposits 1,756,680 1,925,370 1,352,785 Interest-bearing deposits 2,414,656 2,721,309 3,363,815 FHLB advances 30,000 180,000 105,000 Paycheck Protection Program Liquidity Facility — 27,144 191,860 Subordinated notes 107,800 106,957 87,509 Junior subordinated debentures 41,158 40,602 40,072 Total stockholders’ equity 888,971 858,864 726,781 Preferred stockholders' equity 45,000 45,000 45,000 Common stockholders' equity (1) 843,971 813,864 681,781 57 Table of Contents As of and for the years ended December 31, 2022 2021 2020 Per Share Data: Basic earnings per common share $ 4.06 $ 4.44 $ 2.56 Diluted earnings per common share $ 3.96 $ 4.35 $ 2.53 Book value per share $ 35.09 $ 32.35 $ 27.42 Tangible book value per share (1) $ 24.04 $ 21.34 $ 19.78 Shares outstanding end of period 24,053,585 25,158,879 24,868,218 Weighted average shares outstanding - basic 24,393,954 24,736,713 24,387,932 Weighted average shares outstanding - diluted 25,023,568 25,252,052 24,615,816 Adjusted Per Share Data (1) : Adjusted diluted earnings per common share $ 3.96 $ 4.44 $ 2.26 Adjusted weighted average shares outstanding - diluted 25,023,568 25,252,052 24,615,816 Performance ratios: Return on average assets 1.79 % 1.87 % 1.18 % Return on average total equity 11.46 % 14.10 % 9.67 % Return on average common equity 11.69 % 14.52 % 9.77 % Return on average tangible common equity (1) 17.16 % 21.42 % 13.92 % Yield on loans (2) 8.88 % 7.91 % 7.00 % Cost of interest -bearing deposits 0.38 % 0.32 % 0.93 % Cost of total deposits 0.22 % 0.20 % 0.67 % Cost of total funds 0.39 % 0.36 % 0.80 % Net interest margin (2) 7.82 % 6.72 % 5.71 % Efficiency ratio 70.30 % 67.87 % 64.35 % Adjusted efficiency ratio (1) 70.30 % 67.16 % 65.97 % Net noninterest expense to average assets 4.48 % 3.87 % 2.98 % Adjusted net noninterest expense to average total assets (1) 4.48 % 3.82 % 3.14 % Asset Quality ratios (3) : Past due to total loans 2.53 % 2.86 % 3.22 % Nonperforming loans to total loans 1.17 % 0.95 % 1.16 % Nonperforming assets to total assets 1.02 % 0.92 % 1.15 % ACL to nonperforming loans 88.76 % 91.20 % 164.98 % ACL to total loans 1.04 % 0.87 % 1.92 % Net charge-offs to average loans 0.14 % 0.95 % 0.10 % Capital ratios: Tier 1 capital to average assets 13.00 % 11.11 % 10.80 % Tier 1 capital to risk-weighted assets 14.57 % 11.51 % 10.60 % Common equity Tier 1 capital to risk-weighted assets 12.73 % 9.94 % 9.05 % Total capital to risk-weighted assets 17.66 % 14.10 % 13.03 % Total stockholders' equity to total assets 16.67 % 14.42 % 12.24 % Tangible common stockholders' equity ratio (1) 11.41 % 9.46 % 8.56 % (1) The Company uses certain non-GAAP financial measures to provide meaningful supplemental information regarding the Company’s operational performance and to enhance investors’ overall understanding of such financial performance.
Financial Highlights The following table shows selected financial data for each of the years in the three year period ended December 31, 2023: As of and for the years ended December 31, (Dollars in thousands, except per share amounts) 2023 2022 2021 Income Statement Data: Interest income $ 422,421 $ 419,239 $ 387,555 Interest expense 54,342 18,747 18,425 Net interest income 368,079 400,492 369,130 Credit loss expense (benefit) 12,203 6,925 (8,830) Net interest income after provision 355,876 393,567 377,960 Noninterest income 50,173 84,068 54,501 Noninterest expense 353,234 340,631 287,507 Net income before income taxes 52,815 137,004 144,954 Income tax expense 11,734 34,693 31,980 Net income 41,081 102,311 112,974 Dividends on preferred stock (3,206) (3,206) (3,206) Net income available to common stockholders $ 37,875 $ 99,105 $ 109,768 Balance Sheet Data: Total assets $ 5,347,334 $ 5,333,783 $ 5,956,250 Cash and cash equivalents 286,635 408,182 383,178 Investment securities 307,109 263,772 192,877 Loans held for sale 1,236 5,641 7,330 Loans held for investment, net 4,127,881 4,077,484 4,825,359 Total liabilities 4,482,934 4,444,812 5,097,386 Noninterest-bearing deposits 1,632,022 1,756,680 1,925,370 Interest-bearing deposits 2,345,456 2,414,656 2,721,309 FHLB advances 255,000 30,000 180,000 Paycheck Protection Program Liquidity Facility — — 27,144 Subordinated notes 108,678 107,800 106,957 Junior subordinated debentures 41,740 41,158 40,602 Total stockholders’ equity 864,400 888,971 858,864 Preferred stockholders' equity 45,000 45,000 45,000 Common stockholders' equity (1) 819,400 843,971 813,864 59 Table of Contents As of and for the years ended December 31, 2023 2022 2021 Per Share Data: Basic earnings per common share $ 1.63 $ 4.06 $ 4.44 Diluted earnings per common share $ 1.61 $ 3.96 $ 4.35 Book value per share $ 35.16 $ 35.09 $ 32.35 Tangible book value per share (1) $ 24.12 $ 24.04 $ 21.34 Shares outstanding end of period 23,302,414 24,053,585 25,158,879 Weighted average shares outstanding - basic 23,208,086 24,393,954 24,736,713 Weighted average shares outstanding - diluted 23,562,377 25,023,568 25,252,052 Adjusted Per Share Data (1) : Adjusted diluted earnings per common share $ 1.61 $ 3.96 $ 4.44 Performance ratios: Return on average assets 0.76 % 1.79 % 1.87 % Return on average total equity 4.80 % 11.46 % 14.10 % Return on average common equity 4.67 % 11.69 % 14.52 % Return on average tangible common equity (1) 6.91 % 17.16 % 21.42 % Yield on loans (2) 9.20 % 8.88 % 7.91 % Cost of interest -bearing deposits 1.37 % 0.38 % 0.32 % Cost of total deposits 0.83 % 0.22 % 0.20 % Cost of total funds 1.21 % 0.39 % 0.36 % Net interest margin (2) 7.67 % 7.82 % 6.72 % Efficiency ratio 84.45 % 70.30 % 67.87 % Adjusted efficiency ratio (1) 84.45 % 70.30 % 67.16 % Net noninterest expense to average assets 5.58 % 4.48 % 3.87 % Adjusted net noninterest expense to average total assets (1) 5.58 % 4.48 % 3.82 % Asset Quality ratios (3) : Past due to total loans 2.00 % 2.53 % 2.86 % Nonperforming loans to total loans 1.65 % 1.17 % 0.95 % Nonperforming assets to total assets 1.42 % 1.02 % 0.92 % ACL to nonperforming loans 51.15 % 88.76 % 91.20 % ACL to total loans 0.85 % 1.04 % 0.87 % Net charge-offs to average loans 0.47 % 0.14 % 0.95 % Capital ratios: Tier 1 capital to average assets 12.64 % 13.00 % 11.11 % Tier 1 capital to risk-weighted assets 13.74 % 14.57 % 11.51 % Common equity Tier 1 capital to risk-weighted assets 11.94 % 12.73 % 9.94 % Total capital to risk-weighted assets 16.75 % 17.66 % 14.10 % Total stockholders' equity to total assets 16.17 % 16.67 % 14.42 % Tangible common stockholders' equity ratio (1) 11.04 % 11.41 % 9.46 % (1) The Company uses certain non-GAAP financial measures to provide meaningful supplemental information regarding the Company’s operational performance and to enhance investors’ overall understanding of such financial performance.
The following table presents the major categories of credit loss expense (benefit): December 31, 2022 Compared to 2021 2021 Compared to 2020 (Dollars in thousands) 2022 2021 2020 $ Change % Change $ Change % Change Credit loss expense (benefit) on: Loans $ 7,039 $ (7,964) $ 33,981 $ 15,003 188.4 % $ (41,945) (123.4) % Off balance sheet credit exposures (476) (922) 2,448 446 48.4 % (3,370) (137.7) % Held to maturity securities 362 56 1,900 306 546.4 % (1,844) (97.1) % Available for sale securities — — — — — % — — % Total credit loss expense (benefit) $ 6,925 $ (8,830) $ 38,329 $ 15,755 178.4 % $ (47,159) (123.0) % 64 Table of Contents For available for sale debt securities in an unrealized loss position, the Company evaluates the securities at each measurement date to determine whether the decline in the fair value below the amortized cost basis (impairment) is due to credit-related factors or noncredit-related factors.
The following table presents the major categories of credit loss expense (benefit): December 31, 2023 Compared to 2022 2022 Compared to 2021 (Dollars in thousands) 2023 2022 2021 $ Change % Change $ Change % Change Credit loss expense (benefit) on: Loans $ 12,226 $ 7,039 $ (7,964) $ 5,187 73.7 % $ 15,003 188.4 % Off balance sheet credit exposures (769) (476) (922) (293) (61.6) % 446 48.4 % Held to maturity securities 746 362 56 384 106.1 % 306 546.4 % Available for sale securities — — — — — % — — % Total credit loss expense (benefit) $ 12,203 $ 6,925 $ (8,830) $ 5,278 76.2 % $ 15,755 (178.4) % 66 Table of Contents Regarding available for sale debt securities in an unrealized loss position, the Company evaluates the securities at each measurement date to determine whether the decline in the fair value below the amortized cost basis (impairment) is due to credit-related factors or noncredit-related factors.
Credit loss expense for off balance sheet credit exposures increased $0.4 million , primarily due to the changes in the assumptions used to project the loss rates previously discussed as well as changes in the underlying exposures. 65 Table of Contents Noninterest Income The following table presents the major categories of noninterest income: Year ended December 31, 2022 Compared to 2021 2021 Compared to 2020 (Dollars in thousands) 2022 2021 2020 $ Change % Change $ Change % Change Service charges on deposits $ 6,844 $ 7,724 $ 5,274 $ (880) (11.4) % $ 2,450 46.5 % Card income 8,150 8,811 7,781 (661) (7.5) % 1,030 13.2 % Net OREO gains (losses) and valuation adjustments (133) (347) (616) 214 61.7 % 269 43.7 % Net gains (losses) on sale or call of securities 2,512 5 3,226 2,507 N/M (3,221) (99.8 %) Net gains (losses) on sale of loans 18,228 3,105 2,816 15,123 487.1 % 289 10.3 % Fee income 24,222 17,628 6,007 6,594 37.4 % 11,621 193.5 % Insurance commissions 5,145 5,127 4,232 18 0.4 % 895 21.1 % Gain on sale of subsidiary or division — — 9,758 — — % (9,758) (100.0 %) Other 19,100 12,448 21,907 6,652 53.4 % (9,459) (43.2 %) Total noninterest income $ 84,068 $ 54,501 $ 60,385 $ 29,567 54.3 % $ (5,884) (9.7 %) Noninterest income increased $29.6 million, or 54.3%.
Credit loss expense for off balance sheet credit exposures decreased $0.3 million , primarily due to the changes in the assumptions used to project the loss rates previously discussed as well as changes in the underlying exposures. 67 Table of Contents Noninterest Income The following table presents the major categories of noninterest income: Year ended December 31, 2023 Compared to 2022 2022 Compared to 2021 (Dollars in thousands) 2023 2022 2021 $ Change % Change $ Change % Change Service charges on deposits $ 7,001 $ 6,844 $ 7,724 $ 157 2.3 % $ (880) (11.4) % Card income 8,181 8,150 8,811 31 0.4 % (661) (7.5) % Net OREO gains (losses) and valuation adjustments — (133) (347) 133 100.0 % 214 61.7 % Net gains (losses) on sale or call of securities 102 2,512 5 (2,410) (95.9) % 2,507 N/M Net gains (losses) on sale of loans 119 18,228 3,105 (18,109) (99.3) % 15,123 487.1 % Fee income 30,245 24,222 17,628 6,023 24.9 % 6,594 37.4 % Insurance commissions 5,028 5,145 5,127 (117) (2.3) % 18 0.4 % Other (503) 19,100 12,448 (19,603) (102.6) % 6,652 53.4 % Total noninterest income $ 50,173 $ 84,068 $ 54,501 $ (33,895) (40.3) % $ 29,567 54.3 % Noninterest income decreased $33.9 million, or 40.3%.